Sunday, August 22, 2010

Value-added meets Blame+Shame.


4LAKids: Sunday 22•Aug•2010
In This Issue:
• PUBLICATION OF TEACHER DATA DISTRACTS FROM REAL EVALUATION
• UNIONS' TACTICS DIVERGE IN ENGAGING OBAMA AGENDA
• LEAKS DON’T KILL KIDS
• THE LITTLEST REDSHIRTS SIT OUT KINDERGARTEN
• HIGHLIGHTS, LOWLIGHTS & THE NEWS THAT DOESN'T FIT: The Rest of the Stories from Other Sources
• EVENTS: Coming up next week...
• What can YOU do?


Featured Links:
• 4 LAKids on Twitter
• PUBLIC SCHOOLS: an investment we can't afford to cut! - The Education Coalition Website
• 4LAKids Anthology: All the Past Issues, solved, resolved and unsolved!
• 4LAKidsNews: a compendium of recent items of interest - news stories, scurrilous rumors, links, academic papers, rants and amusing anecdotes, etc.
"No one suggests using value-added analysis as the sole measure of a teacher. Many experts recommend that it count for half or less of a teacher's overall evaluation."

– so it says in The LA Times.

Except the 'no one' who suggests it is The Times –and - 'many experts' notwithstanding - they intend to suggest it about six thousand LAUSD third, fourth and fifth grade teachers - ranking them from best-to-worst - perhaps as soon as today.

IN CASE YOU HAVE BEEN OUT THE LOOP THIS WEEK - perhaps visiting the moon to observe the total eclipse of reason on Planet Earth: The LA Times has published an investigative piece identifying and naming the names of good and bad teachers in LAUSD - based on student test scores and calculations founded upon a controversial statistical methodology called "value-added".

If value-added wasn't controversial before, it is now. And if they called in "Bat's-Wing-Added" or "Eye-of-Newt-Added" it wouldn't have gotten any respect whatsoever.

In so doing The Gray Lady of Spring Street set off a brouhaha of epic epicness - to steal some hyperbole from the marketing campaign of Scott Pilgrim v. The World.

The Times piece is described in the Newsweek 'Gaggle' Blog (Press, Politics & Absurdity) thus:

"Do parents have the right to know which of their kids' teachers are the most and least effective? That's the controversy roaring in California this week with the publication of an investigative series by the Los Angeles Times' Jason Song and Jason Felch, who used seven years of math and English test data to publicly identify the best and the worst third- to fifth-grade teachers in the Los Angeles Unified School District. The newspaper's announcement of its plans to release data later this month on all 6,000 of the city's elementary-school teachers has prompted the local teachers' union to rally members to organize a boycott of the newspaper."

Public disclosure of information like this has no precedent. Many school districts are prohibited by law from disclosing the names of ineffective teachers. The teachers interviewed and profiled in last Sunday's expose were interviewed, they met the reporters and posed for the photographers. That can't be said for the 6000 teachers in the database.

The piece by the Two Jasons blew the City of Bell's municipal shenanigans right off the front page. The Bell stories now are a distant second place/below the fold/page 3 in the Times' "Who'll get a Pulitzer?" sweepstakes.

Diane Ravitch has said he methodology here isn’t value added, it's "Blame and Shame - blame and shame the teachers because system doesn't work. Blame and Shame is scapegoating and humiliation, a holdover from the hickory stick and the stocks and pillory. Can the ducking stool and Trial by Ordeal be far behind?

●THE BELL STORIES are real investigative journalism - with wrongdoing and digging and fact checking and muckraking and interviews and leads and reporting.
●The LAUSD STORY is a rewrite of a scholarly report by an economist - How Effective Are Los Angeles Elementary Teachers and Schools? by Richard Buddin [http://bit.ly/azJ68d} - translated into the vernacular and published with 60 point finger-pointing headlines.
●THE STORY IN BELL is about bad politicians.
●THE STORY ABOUT LAUSD is more about the newspaper story and less about teachers and schools; it's bad journalism and the unintended results therefrom. (Though the 'un' in 'unintended' may be as deliberate as The Times' corporate masters and editorial board and the City Hall Power Brokers can make it.)

Historically LA has always been about City Hall power brokers. Historically the LA Times has always been on the power broker's side, And the teachers' union in LA is as much a part of the problem at LAUSD as the part-time power-broker wannabes who complain that the meetings where they give away schools take up too much of their time. And it isn't helpful that the UTLA President argues that teachers are only 10% of the educational equation …though that's about the percentage of the UTLA membership who actually voted for him

Let's face it: Good Teachers make all the difference in the lives of the fortunate students who have them. Poor, mediocre or poorly trained teachers are a problem that needs addressing and solving. The Times would have all teachers not in the top 25% wear distinctive badges, have a stamp on their identity card or a stain on their permanent record.: Bad Teacher. Never to get a job in Lake Woebegone USD - where all teachers and the children are above average!

Just maybe - when the consensus of opinion and the relevant indicators among administrators, peers, students and parents say that a teacher is excellent ....but the data crunched though value-added economic methodology says otherwise ...then maybe the methodology or the data or the theory is suspect. Maybe the value of value-added is subtractive. Maybe economists and newspaper reporters shouldn't be determining teacher performance.

ONE MAY NEVER LEARN TO READ AT GRADE LEVEL (OR ALGEBRA) IN LAUSD ...BUT CYNICISM COMES EASILY.

In an "Informative" to the Board of Ed on Friday and an interview to feed Saturday's Times, Deputy Superintendent Deasy announced that valued-added teachers assessments were 'on-the-table' in union contract negotiations.

● The interview was with Jason Song - one of the 'Two Jason' authors of The Times value-added report - putting Song and The Times in the position of covering news of their own making.
● This perpetuates the unfortunate reality that the UTLA Contract is the overarching governing document of the District and that contract negotiations is where policy is set.
● Deasy cynically (and he's only been here 20 days!) proposed that the contract negotiations be resumed Friday and concluded immediately - before The Times publishes their j'accuse list of suspect teachers - even though UTLA leadership is having their long-scheduled annual meeting in Palm Springs this weekend (in time for the 3.8 temblor Saturday AM!). And UCLA/IDEA predicts The Times will publish their list today!
● 4LAKids' 50-plus years of LAUSD bred-cynicism is fed by the timing of these LAT stories and resultant uproar, the arrival Dr. Deasy fully-formed from the Gates Foundation, the UTLA contact negotiations, the Board of Ed's traditional August Break and - what the heck - the earthquake in PS!

Let me pose a hypothetical, gentle readers - and this will require what those in the entrainment profession call a Suspension of Disbelief ...as I call into question Everything You've Ever Been Told. Make sure those restraints are tightly fastened and keep your hands and arms inside the vehicle at all times: MAYBE THE LA TIMES AND THE UNION AND THE SCHOOL DISTRICT ARE ALL WRONG A LOT OF THE TIME. Or - spoiler alert - had you already figured that out?

Yet the Times is somewhat right.

THERE SHOULD BE A METHODOLOGY FOR EVALUATING TEACHERS .....this just ain't it. (Ironically, Richard Buddin The Times' hired-gun Value-Added theorist/guru/consultant is working on one for his other employer: RAND - employing fixed effects and multilevel modeling approaches to evaluate teacher quality under a five-year Institute of Education Sciences study | http://bit.ly/aTH22F.

AND SOMEONE SHOULD BE IN CHARGE OF EVALUATING TEACHERS - someone we in the parenthood business would call "a responsible adult". The current Board of Ed don't seen up to the job. I sincerely doubt if it's the LA Times and the two Jasons and a think-tank economist. Or Mayor Tony. Or Arne Duncan. Or the Broad, Gates and Walton Family Foundations.

Remember those first three words in the US Constitution? We the People? Maybe it's us who are accountable/responsible/in charge.

¡Onward/Adelante! -smf


PUBLICATION OF TEACHER DATA DISTRACTS FROM REAL EVALUATION
By UCLA/IDEA staff - Themes in the News for the week of Aug. 16-20, 2010

08-20-2010 -- The Los Angeles Times created an uproar in the education community with the publication of a story—the first in a series—that analyzed teacher effectiveness using a value-added model. This weekend, the Times plans to follow up by releasing information about 6,000 third- through fifth-grade teachers, ranking them on a scale from least to most effective.

Reactions of shock and deep concern are coming from many corners of the education community, even those rarely in agreement.

Diane Ravitch, who opposes the use of standardized tests as single tools for evaluation, called the public outing “disgraceful.” | http://bit.ly/d30bHo In a blog post, Rick Hess of the American Enterprise Institute think tank and a proponent of using data for teacher evaluations also said he had serious problems (Education Week | http://bit.ly/aIfz2u).

Value-added analysis measures the movement up or down on a student’s test scores from one year to the next. According to the Times, the higher the jump, the more effective the teacher.

Most expert reports on this method, including one by the National Academy of Science | http://bit.ly/5LWz0, point out that the value-added metric, alone, is insufficient in evaluating teacher effectiveness. In agreement is Los Angeles Unified School District Superintendent Ramon Cortines, who asked, “Would a person be diagnosed with diabetes solely on the basis of a high blood pressure reading? (Color Lines | http://bit.ly/cHHlSZ)

Barnett Berry, president of the Center for Teaching Quality, offered another medical analogy. It is “the equivalent of a newspaper indiscriminately listing the names of doctors, in rank, based on mortality rates, irrespective of the type of medicine they practice or the context in which they practice” (Christian Science Monitor | http://bit.ly/bzAllQ).

A Sacramento high school teacher distinguished between data-driven and data-informed. “In schools that are data-informed, test results are just one more piece of information that can be helpful in determining future directions” (Washington Post | http://bit.ly/c63vAS).

And the data the Times intends to publish is limited in several ways. It purports to identify the value added by particular teachers, but does not take into account student mobility, absenteeism, the role of tutors or team teachers, summer school programs or after-school programs (Christian Science Monitor, Washington Post).

Parents are being invited to act on powerful conclusions they draw from the teacher data, but it is difficult to find positive steps they can take. In the short term, parents might compete among themselves to win their child a spot in the “most effective” teacher’s classroom. School morale, already low after a season of pink slips, could receive another blow. Teachers might do their best to avoid teaching grades 3, 4 and 5. Or, turn inward and narrow their curriculum to teach solely to the test.

Public disclosure and a culture of blame could create a chilling effect on teacher collaboration. It could also dry up the pool of people willing to enter the teaching profession.
People love rankings, sorting, and surveys; it’s hard to resist the appeal of the “10 Best” or “10 Worst”. But the facile display of numbers and rankings can be misleading for a public that is not well acquainted with nuanced statistical models or with critiques of how to use that data.

That is why the National Academy of Sciences worries about the “considerable limitations to the transparency” of value-added analysis.

The Times, by focusing on a narrow and underdeveloped measure of teacher effectiveness, distracts attention from the real reform need: a comprehensive teacher evaluation system that provides ample support to improve student learning.


UNIONS' TACTICS DIVERGE IN ENGAGING OBAMA AGENDA
By Stephen Sawchuk | Education Week | Vol. 30, Issue 01

August 19, 2010 -- Forced into an uneasy balancing act between their members and the president they helped elect, the national teachers’ unions are responding to the Obama administration’s teacher-effectiveness agenda in notably different ways.

Publicly at least, National Education Association President Dennis Van Roekel has hewed closely to the union’s internal policy statements on such matters as embedding student learning into policies on teacher evaluation and pay. But the heads of the union's state affiliates have taken sundry positions on initiatives such as the federal Race to the Top competition, with some participating in the shape of their states’ bids for the $4 billion initiative and others opposing them outright.

In contrast, the president of the 1.5 million-member American Federation of Teachers, Randi Weingarten, has laid out—and helped local affiliates adopt—an explicit agenda for her union that, for example, endorses a new approach to teacher evaluations, including the consideration of test scores alongside other factors.

Those responses, say experts on teachers’ unions, are a complex product molded significantly by the unions’ respective governance structures. Among other differences, the structures make the national bully pulpit a more powerful place at the AFT, but tilt NEA policy away from its president and toward its state affiliates.

“Philosophically, I don’t think [the unions’ leaders] are coming from different places, but there is a difference in the extent to which they’ve engaged in controversial discussions about evaluation and teacher pay,” said Mark Simon, who served as a member of the NEA’s board of directors while the president of its Montgomery County, Md., chapter. “The politics of the organizations allow Randi to be engaged right now, ... while NEA is providing support on an affiliate-by-affiliate basis, but is not able to articulate a message for every affiliate.”

‘NO CONFIDENCE’

After eight years of being largely shut out of policy discussions during President George W. Bush’s administration, the teachers’ unions had hoped for a president friendlier to their views on the teaching profession. And while they’ve had more access to President Barack Obama’s administration, its focus on the controversial area of teacher performance has yielded some angry rank-and-file members.

The differences in the unions’ responses were on stark display at their conventions, both held last month.

Reforming teacher evaluations is arguably the centerpiece of the administration’s teacher-effectiveness conversation. But discussion of the issue was all but absent at the NEA’s Representative Assembly in New Orleans.

Instead, delegates narrowly approved a a position of “no confidence” in the Race to the Top competition, which puts a premium on changing teacher evaluation. The vote largely broke along state-affiliation lines.

“The debate, the closeness of the vote—what you saw was a microcosm of experiences all over the map in terms of negative or positive experiences different states had with the program,” said Ken Swanson, the president of the Illinois Education Association.

The teacher-effectiveness discussion has been pursued individually by select NEA state affiliates rather than at the national level. Unions in Delaware, Illinois, Ohio, Rhode Island, and Tennessee played a major role in the crafting of their states’ applications for the Race to the Top, while other states opposed the grant program altogether.

“We are dead set against tying evaluations to teacher performance and salary,” said David Sanchez, the president of the California Teachers Association. “In my opinion, we are never going to agree to consider that your salary is based on a single evaluative assessment.”

In contrast, Illinois chose to move forward when state lawmakers intentionally included policies reflecting some of the union’s internal priorities in an education reform bill, Mr. Swanson said.

Political realities influenced the Tennessee union’s participation, said Earl Wiman, the past president of the Tennessee Education Association. “We saw the legislative call sheets, and this became a runaway freight train,” he said about a state law created to position the state to compete in the Race to the Top program, which is using economic-stimulus money to promote education improvements along the lines favored by the Obama administration.

Rather than oppose the legislation, the union worked to reduce the percentage of a teacher’s evaluation based on test-score growth and to add provisions to the state code allowing teachers to “grieve,” or formally protest, procedural aspects of their evaluations, Mr. Wiman said.

The NEA did not respond to requests for an interview with Mr. Van Roekel.

EVALUATION ENDORSED

If evaluation was on the periphery of the NEA assembly, it was front and center at the AFT’S biennial convention, held in Seattle. There, AFT delegates formally endorsed a six-page, single-spaced resolution on teacher evaluation codifying the vision Ms. Weingarten had laid out in a speech six months earlier.

In that address at the National Press Club, in Washington, Ms. Weingarten said that under certain circumstances, unions could consider using student achievement in teacher evaluations and align due process procedures with such evaluations. The NEA does not endorse those policies. ("AFT Chief Promises Due-Process Reform," Jan. 20, 2010.)

Since then, Ms. Weingarten has provided crucial bargaining help to local affiliates willing to experiment with evaluation or pay, resulting in a number of high-profile contracts in such cities as New Haven, Conn.; Philadelphia; Pittsburgh; and Washington.

“While the conversation about teacher evaluation may have been started by others, AFT is trying to assert our expertise and authority into that conversation,” said Mary Cathryn Ricker, the president of the union’s St. Paul, Minn., chapter and one of the local leaders Ms. Weingarten tapped to craft the teacher-evaluation framework.

PROPORTIONAL REPRESENTATION

The two national unions’ responses to the teacher-effectiveness issue are not recent phenomena. Rather, they reflect long-standing differences in how the unions are organized.

Under the NEA’s structure, the largest state affiliates—California, New Jersey, Michigan, and Florida, among others—have the most representatives on the union’s board of directors and its resolutions committee, which vets changes to formal NEA policy statements, as well as the most delegates to its convention.

As such, they exert a powerful influence over the national union’s policy direction. The NEA’s resolutions are binding, and the union’s president must abide by them. State affiliates, in theory, must do so to tap their share of centrally allocated NEA funding.

Before this year’s convention, the union’s resolutions committee discussed amending its formal position on teacher evaluations, but it did not advance anything to the delegates, according to the NEA’s executive director, John I. Wilson. And doing so on a controversial issue like teacher evaluations is no easy task.

“To get a resolution to the floor, you really need strong support,” said Keith B. Geiger, the union’s president from 1989 to 1996. “California, New Jersey, Florida—those are states with a lot of resolutions-committee members and ... would be more reticent to pass anything that smells of merit pay, of single tests determining something.”

A downside of the system is that it tethers the national leadership to the traditional positions held by those states, said Julia Koppich, a San Francisco-based consultant who has written extensively on teachers’ unions.

“The organization is split, and it is predictable which states favor some change and which ones don’t,” she said. “If, in fact, the national NEA is more aligned with [the Illinois] positions, it should be out there working with some state affiliates to help them see if they can move a little more toward those positions.”

That the largest 10 affiliates have significant control over policy has complicated Mr. Van Roekel’s relationship with the Obama administration, acknowledged Mr. Sanchez, the president of the California union.

“He is in a very tough situation,” Mr. Sanchez said. “But when he is directed by his board and state presidents, he’s got to go [to the administration] and tell it like it is. It’s challenging for him, just as it is for me to tell him that CTA is not on board with something.”

SINGULAR OPPOSITION

If the NEA structure gives state affiliates the primary role in developing and overseeing policy among local unions, an inverse situation exists within the AFT, where the central leadership actively works to persuade locals to try out new ideas.

The national AFT “treats local leaders as incubators of promising education practices, and they are constantly scanning for things locals are doing that should be scaled up,” said Ms. Ricker, who has worked within both unions’ structures because Minnesota is a merged NEA-AFT affiliate.

That ethos has given Ms. Weingarten an advantage in setting an agenda that goes against some traditionally held views, according to Ms. Koppich. “I think AFT’s philosophy is quite different from the NEA’s, that it’s the elected leadership’s job to maybe take the members to some places they didn’t know they wanted to go,” she said.

What’s more, Ms. Weingarten exerts considerable influence over the union’s policy landscape partly because many of its vice presidents and resolution-vetting committee members belong to the same internal political coalition she supports, the Progressive Caucus. The group is particularly powerful in New York City, the home of the union’s largest affiliate.

It is, in fact, so rare for the AFT’S Progressive Caucus-dominated leadership to be challenged in elections that this year’s convention marked the first time since 1974 that a full opposition slate of candidates ran for office. The slate, which called itself “By Any Means Necessary,” or BAMN, criticized current AFT leaders for considering policy developments such as the Race to the Top competition and teacher evaluations tied in part to student achievement, rather than opposing them altogether. It won about 5 percent of the votes overall.

“It was a message to Randi and a consequence of the risk she’s taken in her leadership role,” said Mr. Simon, the former NEA board member, who is now a policy analyst with the Economic Policy Institute, a think tank in Washington.

Teachers’ union watchers point to Karen Lewis, the new head of the Chicago Teachers’ Union, the AFT’s third-largest affiliate, as a wild card in future AFT policymaking. A newly elected national vice president, she now sits on the union’s executive council.

Though not affiliated with the BAMN slate, Ms. Lewis shares philosophically similar views. She has called the Race to the Top “misguided,” and she opposes many of the Obama administration’s policy prescriptions, including school closures, charter schools, and the use of standardized assessments for judging schools and teachers. Ms. Weingarten has supported such policies, albeit cautiously and only in certain contexts and situations.

Ms. Lewis emerged from a Chicago group, the Caucus Of Rank and File Educators, or CORE. Unlike the loosely affiliated BAMN group, CORE has spent much of its time organizing, and it has already demonstrated its ability to influence policy: At the AFT convention, CORE-affiliated delegates successfully added language eschewing the use of test scores for punitive purposes to a separate resolution on school closures.

The message Ms. Lewis espouses appears to have resonated with the larger AFT. In Seattle, she received the second-highest number of votes for a position on the executive council.

“You will never be heard if all you are doing is screaming and hollering,” Ms. Lewis said, when asked about her new position in the AFT governance. “This is an opportunity for Randi and other people to see how detrimental [the Obama administration’s] policies are.”

For her part, Ms. Weingarten said that she welcomes a variety of opinions on the executive council. “Our council has lots of people with different opinions,” she said. “Karen is about helping kids, and there’s a huge connection there. We have different ideas about how, but our value system is the same.”

MOVING FORWARD

The complicated landscape of the unions’ internal and external messaging on the teacher-effectiveness agenda will continue to play out when renewal of the Elementary and Secondary Education Act comes to the forefront on Capitol Hill.

Most of the NEA’s recent policy shifts on teacher effectiveness have taken place quietly, apart from its slow, deliberative governance structure.
In a largely unnoticed development, Mr. Van Roekel has pledged to support affiliates that take positions outside the union’s formal policy resolutions.

The union’s $6 million Priority Schools campaign, meanwhile, will work with schools receiving grants under the federal School Improvement Grants, even those using improvement models the NEA does not favor.

But the NEA’s national position on teacher-evaluation procedures remains in flux. At the convention, Mr. Van Roekel announced the creation of a new body, the Commission on Effective Teaching, which will report back to the Representative Assembly next year on such issues as teacher evaluation, but its recommendations will not be binding unless they are incorporated into a resolution.

In the meantime, Mr. Van Roekel might try to put forward a more detailed vision for the union in the coming year, his third as NEA president, Mr. Geiger said.

“I think he’s gained a lot of respect,” the former NEA president said. “He’s highly regarded by state leaders. I think he is moving as fast as he can knowing he has both sides of the issue to deal with.”
For Ms. Weingarten of the AFT, the question is a different one: whether the uneasiness she’s faced from limited quarters in response to her push for affiliates to examine long-held ideas about the teaching profession will translate into more-organized action.

“It can grow, or it can die out,” Ms. Ricker of Minnesota said of that pushback. “We are clearly ripe for some internal conversations.”



LEAKS DON’T KILL KIDS
IT IS DEPRESSINGLY UNSURPRISING THAT THE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS WOULD SEE THE DEATHS OF CHILDREN IN THE CARE OF LOS ANGELES COUNTY AS A PUBLICITY PROBLEM, NOT A FAILURE OF THE COUNTY'S MOST BASIC OBLIGATION.

LA Times Editorial

August 21, 2010 -- Faced with a series of administrative lapses that have contributed to the deaths of children in the care of Los Angeles County, the county Board of Supervisors has responded with stern and authoritative action — against the worker or workers who may have brought the tragedies to light.

It is depressingly unsurprising that the board would see these deaths as a publicity problem, not a failure of the county's most basic obligation. As Department of Children and Family Services Director Trish Ploehn described it to the supervisors, the leaks of information regarding child deaths have created a morale issue for her colleagues. Boohoo.

The response to a crisis in child protection might involve overhauling the county's systems for safeguarding children's welfare; it might require firing some inattentive social workers; it might suggest upgrading technology to allow records from the field to be more readily available. But the response to a PR problem suggests a different course: This week, the board authorized a leak investigation.

Supervisor Zev Yaroslavsky, the lone dissenter, aptly noted that "the obsession with leaks … exceeds the obsession with child deaths." He's right, and his colleagues are wrong as they continue to frame the problems of their troubled department as bad press rather than bad management. Moreover, the county's insistence on hushing up these matters has led it to break the law: In contravention of the state law that requires board members to hold their meetings in public, the supervisors initially discussed the leak investigation in closed session. They tried to remedy that this week by at least debating in public, but secrecy is corroding this issue at every step.

On June 8, 11-year-old Jorge Tarin hung himself with a jump-rope hours after a county social worker interviewed him at home and then left him there; this, even though Jorge that same day had told a school counselor and a county worker that he was considering suicide. As the county board considers that tragedy, it should ask itself this question: Who did Jorge more harm? The worker who left him in a home where he complained of being beaten and where his stepfather was residing in defiance of a court order, or the county worker who may have brought details of Jorge's death to light?
●●smf: Supervisor Yaroslavsky and The LA Times have this right. Children are dying. This is a more important story than the malfeasance in Bell or the LAUSD teacher assessments put together.

Make a note:

● TO THE BOARD OF SUPES: Stop looking for scapegoats and whistleblowers and do something. It may very well be that the current Department of Children and Family Services is doing the best they can with their limited staff and budget. If that is true the board bears responsibility for the death of children and the bad press.
● TO THE PULITIZER COMMITTEE: This is what good investigative journalism and good editorial writing looks like.


THE LITTLEST REDSHIRTS SIT OUT KINDERGARTEN
By PAMELA PAUL | New York Times

August 20, 2010 -- AFTER all those attentive early childhood rituals — the flashcards, the Kumon, the Dora the Explorer, the mornings spent in cutting-edge playgrounds — who wouldn’t want to give their children a head start when it’s finally time to set off for school?

Suzanne Collier, for one. Rather than send her 5-year-old son, John, to kindergarten this year, the 36-year-old mother from Brea, Calif., enrolled him in a “transitional” kindergarten “without all the rigor.” He’s an active child, Ms. Collier said, “and not quite ready to focus on a full day of classroom work.” Citing a study from “The Tipping Point” about Canadian hockey players, which found that the strongest players were the oldest, she said, “If he’s older, he’ll have the strongest chance to do the best.”

Hers is a popular school of thought, and it is not new. “Redshirting” of kindergartners — the term comes from the practice of postponing the participation of college athletes in competitive games — became increasingly widespread in the 1990s, and shows no signs of waning.

In 2008, the most recent year for which census data is available, 17 percent of children were 6 or older when they entered the kindergarten classroom. Sand tables have been replaced by worksheets to a degree that’s surprising even by the standards of a decade ago. Blame it on No Child Left Behind and the race to get children test-ready by third grade: Kindergarten has steadily become, as many educators put it, “the new first grade.”

What once seemed like an aberration — something that sparked fierce dinner party debates — has come to seem like the norm. But that doesn’t make it any easier for parents.

“We agonized over it all year,” said Rachel Tayse Baillieul, a food educator in Columbus, Ohio, where the cutoff date is Oct. 1. Children whose birthdates fall later must wait until the next year to start school. But her daughter, Lillian, 4, was born five days before, on Sept. 25, which would make her one of the youngest in the class.

With the wide age spans in kindergarten classrooms, each new generation of preschool parents must grapple with where exactly to slot their children. Wiggly, easily distracted and less mature, boys are more likely to be held back than girls, but delayed enrollment is now common for both sexes.

“Technically, Lillian could go to kindergarten,” Ms. Tayse Baillieul said. Moving her up from part-time preschool would allow Ms. Tayse Baillieul to return to work and earn income. But Lillian’s preschool teachers counseled her to hold Lillian back. “They said staying in preschool a year longer will probably never hurt and will probably always help, especially with social and emotional development.”

Regardless, a classroom with an 18-month age spread will create social disparities. “Someone has to be the youngest in class,” pointed out Susan Messina, a 46-year-old mother in Washington. “No matter how you slice it.” When Clare, her daughter, who is now 9, entered kindergarten at 4, Ms. Messina was aware of widespread redshirting.

“I thought, I’m not breaking the rules, I’m not pushing her ahead, we’re doing exactly what we’re supposed to do,” she said. “Then it dawned on me that in this day and age, there’s a move to keep your brilliant angel in preschool longer so they could be smarter and taller for the basketball team. But my daughter doesn’t need a leg up. She’s fine.”

Still, it bothers her that children in the same class are as much as a year and a half older than Clare. “She has friends who are 11 who are going to get their periods this year, and she’s still playing with American Girl dolls.” Another mother complained that her 4-year-old became hooked on Hannah Montana by her aspiring-tween classmates. A 6-year-old wielding a light saber can be awfully intimidating to a boy who still sleeps with his teddy.

At the other tip of the age span, parents who promote children to kindergarten before 5 are often seen as pushy, “even ogre-ish,” Ms. Messina said. But suppose your child is already reading at 4? Do you hold her back where she may be bored to tears in preschool or send her into a classroom of hulking 6-year-old boys? In 1970, 14.4 percent of kindergartners started at age 4. That figure has dropped to less than 10 percent.

The self-esteem movement has inspired parents to care as much about emotional well-being as academic achievement, and with fragile self-images still in the making, the worst fear for parents is setting up their children for failure. One Connecticut mother in Fairfield County sent her October-born son to kindergarten at 4, despite “the informal rule of thumb that everyone holds back their September to December boys.” Kindergarten seemed to go well, but when her son entered first grade, she said, “I got hit over the head. They told me he was way behind.”

She watched in horror as her son’s self-confidence tanked. “He was spinning his wheels just to keep up,” she recalled. “He even got pulled out of class for poor handwriting.” At the end of a miserable second-grade year, she withdrew him to repeat the grade at a private school. “It’s been a long and difficult journey,” she said. “I totally regret starting him on kindergarten at 4.”

Many parents feel compelled to redshirt by what they see as unreasonable academic demands for 4- and 5-year-olds. But keeping children in preschool, according to both academic research and parental experience, doesn’t necessarily offer every advantage. Jennifer Harrison, a mother of two from Folsom, Calif., held her October-born son, Elliott, back so he “wouldn’t get labeled as out of control.” Over all, she said, it was the right decision. “But his math skills are far above those of his classmates.”

How to attend to a child’s myriad needs, and which should be the priority? “There don’t seem to be any rules,” said Rebecca Meekma, a mother of two from Laguna Beach, Calif. “People are saying, ‘I want him to be big in high school for sports!’ What is that? You can’t know who they’ll be in high school.”

And what about children who aren’t Leo the Late Bloomer? “I have met mom after mom who is intentionally holding her child back a year,” said Jennifer Finke, a mother of two in Englewood, Colo. “They say they don’t want their kids to be the youngest or shortest. Is that right? Is it fair?”

Ms. Finke’s son, Benjamin, is soon to start kindergarten at 5. “There will be boys in his class who are a year or more older than him. They’ll be bored in class and then the bar will be set higher, and the kids who are the right age will find that they can’t keep up.” What will happen in gym when the larger boys are picked first for brute force, leaving the pipsqueaks languishing? “I’m afraid my children will feel inferior.”

Not all parents can choose when their children begin kindergarten. “Though redshirting is common in the suburbs, in Manhattan, it’s the schools — not parents — who decide,” said Emily Glickman, whose company, Abacus Guide Educational Consulting, advises parents on kindergarten admissions. At New York City private schools, the cutoff date is Sept. 1; in practice, summer babies, particularly boys, generally enter kindergarten at age 6. “It’s a ramped-up world,” Ms. Glickman said. “And the easiest way for schools to assure that their kids do better is for them to be older and more mature.”

Meanwhile, New York City public schools have a firm age cutoff date of Dec. 31. Kindergarten isn’t required by the state, so parents could keep their children out, but then they would have to start the following year at first grade. And not everyone can afford two to three years of nursery school or day care.

“Among parents here, there’s a tremendous demand for kindergarten earlier,” said Eva Moskowitz, founder of the Harlem Success Academy Charter School, which pushed its cutoff back to Dec. 1. “If these parents could start their kids at 2, they would.” Not everyone, alas, defines academic privilege the same way.


HIGHLIGHTS, LOWLIGHTS & THE NEWS THAT DOESN'T FIT: The Rest of the Stories from Other Sources

GOOD GRADES: Teachers must be held accountable for students' success - and failure: L.A. DAILY NEWS EDITORIAL 8/2... http://bit.ly/cS8EgR

LEAKS DON’T KILL KIDS: LA Times Editorial It is depressingly unsurprising that the Board of Supervisors would see... http://bit.ly/ciFkbP

L.A. UNIFIED PRESSES UNION ON TEST SCORES + UTLA HEAD SAYS HE’S OPEN TO NEW EVALUATION SYSTEM + smf's 2¢:: ●●smf's... http://bit.ly/dtU5BD

EDUCATION EXPERTS SLAM LA TIMES TEACHER ASSESSMENTS: By Robert Cruickshank | Published on California Progress Repo... http://bit.ly/bALkSw


LA TIMES STORY A GAME CHANGER: by Charles Kerchner in HuffingtonPost.com , later (8-20)in CityWatch 8/16/201... http://bit.ly/cvs8hi

THE IGUANA, THE GOAT AND THE PONY: A TALE OF COLLABORATION: MY TURN BY Diana L. Chapman | from CityWatch – an insi... http://bit.ly/deyxQb

THE PROMISE OF EARLY COLLEGE: “The importance of collaboration between institutions of higher education and high s... http://bit.ly/9FscAS

U.S. DEPT OF EDUCATION – OFFICE OF THE INSPECTOR GENERAL – Final Management Information Report: CHARTER SCHOOL VUL... http://bit.ly/bY59zf

TEACHERS’ UNION LEADER SAYS PARENTS SHOULD KNOW TEACHERS’ RATINGS: But Randi Weingarten, president of the American... http://bit.ly/bC983J

Education groups outraged: STATE COULD USE FEDERAL SCHOOL FUNDING TO HELP CLOSE BUDGET GAP. The $1.2 billion was s... http://bit.ly/9t4zcx

Newsweek: L.A. TIMES RANKS CITY TEACHERS BY EFFECTIVENESS: from the Newsweek Gaggle Blog: Press, Politics & Absurd... http://bit.ly/dCqv5T

Action Required: SUPPORT ACCESS TO FREE, FRESH DRINKING WATER IN SCHOOLS: from the California Center for Public He... http://bit.ly/bVfGN4

LAUSD MAY HOLD OFF ON SPENDING FEDERAL “SAVE JOBS AID” …IN APPARENT VIOLATION OF ‘SUPPLEMENT v. SUPPLANT’ RULE.: (... http://bit.ly/aAIhP4

CAMPUS UNDER LAUSD's SCHOOL CHOICE PLAN OPENS. EXPERIMENT: Camino Nuevo Academy to be closely watched test case ... http://bit.ly/cd6Ak5

CONGRESS TO INVESTIGATE SCHOOL TURNAROUND COMPANIES + INEXPERIENCED COMPANIES CHASE U.S. SCHOOL FUNDS: Congress to... http://bit.ly/9PkVlX

Willingham: BIG QUESTIONS ABOUT THE LA TIMES TEACHERS PROJECT: washingtonpost.com > Education > The Answer S... http://bit.ly/baEsnz

LOS ANGELES TIMES PLANS TO PUBLISH DATABASE REVEALING INDIVIDUAL TEACHER PERFORMANCE IN LAUSD: Compiled by CityTow... http://bit.ly/cjnBjq

THE LA TIMES AT ITS BEST(?): ●●There is more than one way to look at any issue. In the interest of total fairness this isn't one of them! http://bit.ly/cNqugl
LA TIMES JOINS THE TEACHER-BASHING PARADE: by Julianne Hing| ColorLines: After 12 years as a print magazine, Color... http://bit.ly/akxeg9

IS THIS AN INVITATION FOR TEACHER-SHOPPING?: EDITORIAL IN The Bakersfield Californian Tuesday, Aug 17 2010 03:51... http://bit.ly/aY3iJw

SCHOOL FUNDING UPDATES: From The National Access Network at Teachers College, Columbia University 17 August 2010... http://bit.ly/b5nhmS

THE CHARTER SCHOOL COMMUNITY THINKS THIS NEWS IS NEWSWORTHY….: from Education news bulletin of LAEdupreneurs Tue... http://bit.ly/aAvyv6

from NPR: L.A. TIMES ANALYZING AND RANKING -or ‘NAMING AND SHAMING’ - LOS ANGELES TEACHERS: from national public r... http://bit.ly/bUxngg

TEACHERS UNIONS /UNION RAGE: BY R.M. IN THE ECONOMIST American politics Democracy in America Aug 17th 2010,... http://bit.ly/cKvhxO

‘DREAM ACT’ WOULD NOT BE ENOUGH FOR MANY UNDOCUMENTED STUDENTS: photo: Jay Premack - Students gathered in Washingt... http://bit.ly/bZqWh4

MONEY FOR CALIF. SCHOOLS LIKELY TO BE DELAYED: ABC7 Eyewitness News HD covering Los Angeles and Southern Californi... http://bit.ly/aL6DsH

LAUSD STUDENTS IMPROVE PROFICIENCY ON STATEWIDE ENGLISH, MATH TESTS + NEW CA TEST SCORES SHOW SCHOOLS FARING BETTE... http://bit.ly/9drr5v


EVENTS: Coming up next week...
*Dates and times subject to change. ________________________________________
• SCHOOL CONSTRUCTION BOND OVERSIGHT COMMITTEE:
http://www.laschools.org/bond/
Phone: 213-241-5183
____________________________________________________
• LAUSD FACILITIES COMMUNITY OUTREACH CALENDAR:
http://www.laschools.org/happenings/
Phone: 213-241.8700


• LAUSD BOARD OF EDUCATION & COMMITTEES MEETING CALENDAR



What can YOU do?
• E-mail, call or write your school board member:
Yolie.Flores.Aguilar@lausd.net • 213-241-6383
Tamar.Galatzan@lausd.net • 213-241-6386
Monica.Garcia@lausd.net • 213-241-6180
Marguerite.LaMotte@lausd.net • 213-241-6382
Nury.Martinez@lausd.net • 213-241-6388
Richard.Vladovic@lausd.net • 213-241-6385
Steve.Zimmer@lausd.net • 213-241-6387
...or your city councilperson, mayor, the governor, member of congress, senator - or the president. Tell them what you really think! • Find your state legislator based on your home address. Just go to: http://bit.ly/dqFdq2 • There are 26 mayors and five county supervisors representing jurisdictions within LAUSD, the mayor of LA can be reached at mayor@lacity.org • 213.978.0600
• Call or e-mail Governor Schwarzenegger: 213-897-0322 e-mail: http://www.govmail.ca.gov/
• Open the dialogue. Write a letter to the editor. Circulate these thoughts. Talk to the principal and teachers at your local school.
• Speak with your friends, neighbors and coworkers. Stay on top of education issues. Don't take my word for it!
• Get involved at your neighborhood school. Join your PTA. Serve on a School Site Council. Be there for a child.
• If you are eligible to become a citizen, BECOME ONE.
• If you a a citizen, REGISTER TO VOTE.
• If you are registered, VOTE LIKE THE FUTURE DEPENDS ON IT.


Who are your elected federal & state representatives? How do you contact them?




Scott Folsom is a parent leader in LAUSD. He is Past President of Los Angeles Tenth District PTSA and represents PTA on the LAUSD Construction Bond Citizen's Oversight Committee. He is an elected Representative on his neighborhood council. He is a Health Commissioner, Legislation Team member and a member of the Board of Managers of the California State PTA. He serves on numerous school district advisory and policy committees and has served as a PTA officer and governance council member at three LAUSD schools. He is the recipient of the UTLA/AFT 2009 "WHO" Gold Award for his support of education and public schools - an honor he hopes to someday deserve. • In this forum his opinions are his own and your opinions and feedback are invited. Quoted and/or cited content copyright © the original author and/or publisher. All other material copyright © 4LAKids.
• FAIR USE NOTICE: This site contains copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. 4LAKids makes such material available in an effort to advance understanding of education issues vital to parents, teachers, students and community members in a democracy. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes.
• To SUBSCRIBE e-mail: 4LAKids-subscribe@topica.email-publisher.com - or -TO ADD YOUR OR ANOTHER'S NAME TO THE 4LAKids SUBSCRIPTION LIST E-MAIL smfolsom@aol.com with "SUBSCRIBE" AS THE SUBJECT. Thank you.



Sunday, August 15, 2010

There is no time like the present to live in the moment.


4LAKids: Sunday 15•August•2010
In This Issue:
• MANY SCHOOLS ON CONTROVERSIAL REFORM LIST MAY NOT GET A DIME OF $416 MILLION: LAUSD didn't include enough struggling schools in funding application
• Showtime: CALIFORNIA SCHOOL CHIEFS COMPETE FOR RACE TO THE TOP DOLLARS
• U.S. to States: COME GET YOUR EDUCATION JOBS FUND MONEY
• The Police Blotter: IVY ACADEMIA CHARTER SCHOOL OFFICIAL MISUSED $200,000 IN PUBLIC FUNDS + THE SCANDAL IN BELL BRINGS $2.9 MILLION TO SCHOOLS
• HIGHLIGHTS, LOWLIGHTS & THE NEWS THAT DOESN'T FIT: The Rest of the Stories from Other Sources
• EVENTS - Coming up next week: TALES OF TWO SCHOOL DISTRICTS: LAUSD’s HUGE DISPARITIES & HOW TO FIX THEM
• What can YOU do?


Featured Links:
• 4 LAKids on Twitter
• PUBLIC SCHOOLS: an investment we can't afford to cut! - The Education Coalition Website
• 4LAKids Anthology: All the Past Issues, solved, resolved and unsolved!
• 4LAKidsNews: a compendium of recent items of interest - news stories, scurrilous rumors, links, academic papers, rants and amusing anecdotes, etc.
LAUSD IS POISED TO BEGIN A NEW SCHOOL YEAR. School has already begun at the few remaining year 'round schools - and at three 'early start' high schools. On Monday 17 more early start high schools open. I have concerns about tinkering with the calendar - and not because the 9 months of school/3 months of summer vacation is written in stone or the greatest thing since sliced bread. (It's not - and it predates sliced bread!) I'm concerned because the whole effort is engineered to improve test scores. Not instruction; test scores. See Supt Cortines comments here: http://bit.ly/NVqYI

This is not transformative, different or challenging change; it's eyewash. This isn't reform to better educate children - or educate better children -- we're trying to improve test scores.

When do we - when do they - get it? The data isn't the outcome ...it's an indicator!

We are challenging parents and families by putting their children in elementary and middle schools and high school on different calendars. And, if one is believe the Daily News story, not doing a very good job of telling families about the new calendars.

● Rather than start high school a month early, why not try starting it an hour late?

There is conclusive evidence that shows starting high school later in the day improves education outcomes.- we know that high school kids learn better and smarter later in the day..And incidentally, they test better, (We also know it doesn't work that way for elementary and middle.) I'm not hearing a whole lot about changing the bell schedule. Plus, think of the surprised slackers that won't be caught in the tardy sweeps!

AS I WRITE THIS there are four news stories about LAUSD and public education on the online equivalent of the wires: ● The possible preservation of up to 2500 LAUSD jobs by the US Congress | http://bit.ly/bjZAvh ● The California application for Race to the Top | http://bit.ly/9YuaWo ● The possible loss of the Program Improvement Grants because the applications were not properly filed | http://bit.ly/bOtUpb ● and the change in the calendar reported above

THE FIRST, SECOND and THIRD show the new dependence on federal funding by public education. Most money for K-12 in California still comes from the state - but it's become obvious that the critical funding - the money that potentially makes the difference at the tipping point between success and failure (no matter how you measure it) - comes from the Feds. This funding doesn't go necessarily go to the districts, schools, classrooms or children that need it ...it goes to those that make the most convincing case that they need it.

IN THE CASE OF RACE TO THE TOP - THE SEQUEL - the team from California - which included Supt. Cortines - made a half-hour pitch and took an hour of questions from Dept of Ed bureaucrats in DC after over 100 hours of rehearsal and prep and watching You Tube. [Showtime: CALIFORNIA SCHOOL CHIEFS COMPETE FOR RACE TO THE TOP DOLLARS | http://bit.ly/9YuaWo]

It's pleasant if not exactly encouraging to know that the"The Pitch" - the same methodology used to green-light television series and reality programs - decides the future of our nation's children. This becomes even more problematic when you realize that the pitchmen are the same wonderful folks who didn’t follow the rules on the School Improvement Grant Application. [MANY SCHOOLS ON CONTROVERSIAL REFORM LIST MAY NOT GET A DIME OF $416 MILLION | http://bit.ly/bOtUpb]

Public education is being played as a game of 'gotcha' and decided as a beauty contest - and LAUSD is no one's paradigm of pulchritude. Kipling praised those that could "risk it all on one turn of pitch-and-toss" ...but he thought the blunder of the Light Brigade was heroic.

THIS IS THE TIME FOR THE ADULTS IN LAUSD TO GET REAL.

We need to start by reading the specs and filling out the grant applications by following the rules.

We needed to have had - AND NOW MORE THAN EVER: WE NEED TO HAVE honest and meaningful conversations with the stakeholders about the impact of consequences (anticipated and unintended) of flexibility in funding categorical programs like class size reduction, adult ed, GATE, counselors, deferred maintenance, violence prevention, etc. [Chances are, if you liked the program, it's on the list: http://bit.ly/cSTIjP] The legislation that allowed flexibility and waiver of categorical programs didn't mandate them - it permitted them - after meaningful discussion at the local Board of Ed.

The LAUSD board showed little or no flex in their flexibility; they cut and eliminated funding piecemeal - if they could, they did!

The final decisions to cut or eliminate categorical programs weren't made in Sacramento, they were made at Beaudry - not as policy decisions but as done-deals in the budget process, -- passed as up-or-down votes: "Thank you for your three minutes of public comment. Call for the question.. Without objection? Passed. Next item."

There is no accountability in the accounting, it is as transparent as a brick wall. All in all, another brick in the wall ....We don't get no education. That wall!

Every corporation should have a Budget and Finance Committee on their board.

LAUSD is the second largest corporate entity in LA County, second only to the county itself. But the LAUSD's board has NO committees - a decision made to streamline the process, move things along and save the money (and time and bother) that actually having meetings cost! I suppose the easiest way around California's Brown Act - the Open Meetings Law - is to have no meetings ay all.

I'm going to posit here that if any billion-dollar-plus publicly traded corporation didn’t have a Budget and Finance Committee 'Sixty Minutes' would come to call ...and the Security and Exchange Commission ( and Congress) would investigate ....and would probably shut them down.


"THE JANITORIAL STAFF WAS LET GO IN THE LAST BUDGET CUT," Jack Slater, the governor's fictional aide tells Megan Fox in the Hot for Teachers Video.. "But let's not forget that when Governor Schwarzenegger was a boy he gathered up all the trash in his village and burned it to keep his family warm in the cold Austrian winter." - http://bit.ly/dtzChZ

AT A SCHOOL BUDGET MEETING ON THURSDAY THE NEW DISTRICTWIDE SCHOOL MAINTENANCE BUDGET & SCHEDULE - AND HOW IT IMPACTS THE LOCAL SCHOOL - WAS DISCUSSED - whereby school plant managers (head custodians) will no longer be dedicated to school sites but rather will be in charge of traveling crews going from school-to-school - working in the afternoons and evenings. At another meeting I actually had LAUSD Maintenance & Operations people attempt to explain to me how this would improve test scores ....though neither I nor they believed a word of it.

At the school budget meeting a parent representative asked if the school could use their limited and vanishing discretionary funds - or even parent raised funds - to supplement cleaning and custodial services - and was told "absolutely not!" Inadequate is apparently enough - or at least all you're allowed.

So much for school-based decision making.

Meanwhile the LAUSD Facilities Services Division is creating a program (with the code name of "The Company") that will offer premium LAUSD Maintenance+Operations services to charter schools on an "as much as you want to pay for" basis.

So much for for equity.

FINALLY (all this fun has to end sometime ...please!) BUT WITH LITTLE FINALITY: Today The LA Times began a in-depth series of articles about rating teachers - to guarantee the controversy the series is provocatively titled: GRADING THE TEACHERS | http://bit.ly/9rE3xm -(follow the link - the article is too long for the 4LAKids newsletter.)The article advocates for for a statistical methodology called 'value-added analysis",to evaluate teachers. For a technical explanation and some actual scholarship (what a concept!) see: http://bit.ly/azJ68d

The Times takes LAUSD to task for not using the statistical model - and then self congratulates:

"In coming months, The Times will publish a series of articles and a database analyzing individual teachers' effectiveness in the nation's second-largest school district — the first time, experts say, such information has been made public anywhere in the country."

The Times continues: "The respected National Academy of Sciences weighed in last October, saying the approach was promising but should not be used in "high stakes" decisions — firing teachers, for instance — without more study."

Isn't naming names and pointing fingers at individual classroom teachers - who are neither public officials nor celebrities - in a mass circulation metropolitan daily newspaper "high stakes"?

The Times goes on: "This summer, one district took a harder line: Washington, D.C., schools Chancellor Michelle Rhee fired 26 teachers based in significant part on their poor value-added scores."

So much for Chancellor Rhee's respect for the National Academy of Sciences.

The Times evidence implies that some teachers universally respected for being good teachers are actually bad teachers.

The Times ran their statistical model on data obtained under the Freedom of Information Act, unilaterally and publicly evaluating over 6000 LAUSD teachers - and intends to publish their findings. Some will contend this is a piece of gotcha WikiLeaks journalism. And by comparing this database with the Daily News publication of LAUSD's payroll database last year [http://bit.ly/cA7BE0] we will all be able to to run our own program comparing teacher performance, student test scores and salary - a true ROI (Return on Investment) 'bang-for-buck' business study. That way our decision process can be driven by money rather than test scores. So we speed down the Race-to-the-Top racetrack, putting the pedal to the metal -- Data Driven to Distraction and hell-bent for the Destruction Derby.

● "There are three kinds of lies: lies, damned lies, and statistics." - Benjamin Disraeli -- the quote popularized the U.S. by Mark Twain.

● Twain himself said: "First God made idiots, that was for practice. Then He created school boards".

Having called my two expert witnesses, I rest my case.

¿Onward/Adelante? - smf


SUNDAY FUNNIES: This week’s Sunday Frazz is too true, Dilbert is truer still.



MANY SCHOOLS ON CONTROVERSIAL REFORM LIST MAY NOT GET A DIME OF $416 MILLION: LAUSD didn't include enough struggling schools in funding application
LAUSD OFFICIALS: "We were never told of such a requirement."

by Corey G. Johnson in California WatchBlog - A Project of the Center for Investigative Reporting

August 11, 2010 | If federal officials don't waive key rules, several of the state's largest school districts are at risk of not getting one penny of a nearly $416 million grant to turn around struggling campuses.

According to an Aug. 10 letter sent to the U.S. Department of Education, state officials are asking federal authorities to reconsider the rule requiring California to put 25 percent of its $415,844,376 away for next year – which equates to roughly $100 million.

The request comes as state officials take heat over the decision to only fund reforms at 95 of the 188 schools on the controversial "persistently under-performing" list. As first reported by blogger John Fensterwald, districts whose funding applications got rejected for a slice of the federal School Improvement Grant (SIG) included Los Angeles Unified, Oakland Unified, Sacramento City Unified and Compton – all areas with sizable communities in need of aid. This news means that with the first day of school merely days away, districts who sought to improve by firing staff, revamping curriculum and taking on longer school days could end up with no money to see those reforms through.

According to the letter from state Superintendent of Public Instruction Jack O'Connell and state board president Ted Mitchell:

California had 188 Tier I and Tier II schools identified as persistently lowest-achieving. As indicated in the tables above, we did not receive applications for all of those schools, and only 95 of the 188 Tier I and Tier II schools have approvable applications. Nevertheless, 75 percent of the SIG grant will not fund all approvable Tier I and Tier II schools. The additional 25 percent is needed to provide maximum funding for this year’s cohort of persistently lowest-achieving schools.

The requested waiver will increase the quality of instruction for more students and improve the academic achievement of students in a greater number of schools identified as Tier I and Tier II by enabling more schools and (local educational agencies) to benefit from the SIG program this year in implementing one of the four intervention models established by your agency.

In particular, LAUSD, the nation's second largest school district, was extremely unhappy with its snub. State officials, according to Fensterwald, said LA lost out because it didn't include enough struggling schools in its funding application. They had 30 schools on the state list but only requested funding for 13 campuses. LAUSD officials retorted they were never told of such a requirement.

Finger pointing aside, the bottom line is this: If federal authorities don't now agree to waive the requirements and free up more money, there may be little more that can be done – which ultimately means some of the biggest districts in the state would also be the biggest funding losers.

For several local school leaders, such an outcome would be bitterly ironic. When the state attached tough reforms to vie for the funds, reforms that included firing all the staff and principal; turning the school into a charter; or simply shutting the campus down – many on the local level thought such moves were so unfair and distasteful, they would take a pass.

Yet, the turmoil and despair triggered by the ongoing budget crisis, forced a change of heart. If this ultimately fails, what will this mean for the push for reform? And just how does all of this improve the lives of the children in these so-called struggling schools?


CDE's August Letter to USDOE



Showtime: CALIFORNIA SCHOOL CHIEFS COMPETE FOR RACE TO THE TOP DOLLARS
by Kitty Felde | KPCC

Aug. 11, 2010 | It was show time in Washington, D.C. this week for California education leaders. They competed with 18 other states for federal Race to the Top education grants. The team had 30 minutes to present its case and an hour to defend it.

The last time California competed for Race to the Top dollars, it finished in 27th place.

This time, the team enlisted local school superintendents Ramon Cortines of Los Angeles Unified and Chris Steinhauser of Long Beach.

They spent more than 100 hours preparing for the 90-minute presentation.

California’s education secretary Bonnie Reiss says they studied what ad worked for winners in the first round.

"All their presentations were posted on YouTube," Reiss said. "So part of our prep was reviewing that."

The key, says Reiss, was convincing federal officials that with the money, California can use data to help identify talented teachers and teaching methods that work.

Using good data can identify inspiring educators.

"Certain teachers were doing incredibly well with teaching the kids in math and in English and in science and they modeled that and then that teacher became a mentor teacher and they used them as coaches and student improvement went up across the board," she said.

This time, the California team also got cooperation from teachers unions on methods to measure teacher effectiveness.

There’s a lot at stake: California could get $700 million dollars.

The feds will decide which dozen or so states will get the money before the school year begins in most districts next month.


U.S. to States: COME GET YOUR EDUCATION JOBS FUND MONEY
By Alyson Klein | Education Week

August 13, 2010 2:35 PM | U.S. Secretary of Education Arne Duncan wasn't kidding when he promised school districts and states that the applications for the new Education Jobs Fund (created under the $10 billion edujobs bill) would be very quick and "streamlined."

Less than a week after President Obama signed the edujobs bill, the application has been posted, and it is super straightforward. There is basically only one question: States have to specify whether they plan to distribute the funds through Title I or through their state education funding formula. (Except for Texas, which is special, and gets no choice in the matter. Texas has to distribute the funds via Title I. And, it has stricter maintenance-of-effort provisions.)

The money can be used for restoring cuts in salaries and benefits and boosting teacher pay in the 2010-2011 school year. Districts can also eliminate furlough days that had been scheduled for the 2010-2011 school year.

But they can't use the funds to pay salaries and benefits for outside contractors, except in cases where districts contract with other districts for specific services. And the money can't be used for central office staff.


Districts can use the funds to pay the salaries of teachers and other employees, including principals, assistant principals, academic coaches, in-service teacher trainers, classroom aides, counselors, librarians, secretaries, social workers, psychologists, interpreters, physical therapists, speech therapists, occupational therapists, information technology personnel, nurses, athletic coaches, security officers, custodians, maintenance workers, bus drivers, and cafeteria workers.


from US Dept of Ed: Education Jobs Fund



The Police Blotter: IVY ACADEMIA CHARTER SCHOOL OFFICIAL MISUSED $200,000 IN PUBLIC FUNDS + THE SCANDAL IN BELL BRINGS $2.9 MILLION TO SCHOOLS
► Court Documents: IVY ACADEMIA CHARTER SCHOOL OFFICIAL MISUSED $200,000 IN PUBLIC FUNDS

By Connie Llanos, Staff Writer | LA Daily News

8/13/2010 | 7:44:52 PM PDT -- A $995 CD set on "how to avoid paying taxes" was among the items an Ivy Academia charter school official purchased with more than $200,000 in misused public funds, authorities alleged in court documents unsealed this week.

The husband-and-wife team that runs the high-performing West Valley charter school was charged in June by the Los Angeles District Attorney's Public Integrity Division with 38 felony and misdemeanor crimes, including misuse of public funds, embezzlement, money laundering and tax fraud.

Eugene Selivanov, 38, and his wife, Tatyana Berkovich, 32, operate Ivy Academia, an independently run charter school in the West San Fernando Valley that is funded with state and federal dollars.

The couple has temporarily stepped down from the school's board of directors and will remove themselves from day-to-day operations when a new interim director is in place, at least for the course of the trial, district officials and the couple's attorney said Friday.

Selivanov and Berkovich were unavailable for comment Friday, but their attorneys said the couple are innocent of all charges.

"We are confident the evidence will reveal that Eugene and Tatyana have always acted in the best interest of Ivy, its students and families," said Jeff Rutherford, with the firm Crowell & Moring.

Affidavits unsealed by the District Attorney's office this week allege that Selivanov transferred public funds to for-profit company bank accounts and to himself, and used public funds to pay credit-card bills not tied to the schools.

For example on May 25, 2007, the documents said, Selivanov wrote a check for $50,000 from Ivy Academia's Support Fund Account — set up to collect donations for the public school — to Ivy Academia's general account.

On the same day Selivanov wrote a check for $30,000 from Ivy Academia's account to Egeneration LLC, the bank account for one of the couple's private businesses, and later wrote a check to himself from that account for $30,000 that was later deposited in his personal bank account, the documents said.

On May 30, 2007, Selivanov transferred $24,000 from his personal account to pay Citibank credit card charges, the documents said.

Investigators dug through boxes of bank and credit card statements, receipts and tax documents confiscated from the couple's West Valley home, their accountant's house and their four school campuses.

They describe finding "questionable charges" totaling some $96,000 on the couple's American Express credit card, including $3,000 for a community property investment seminar, $995 for the CD set, and about $9,000 in restaurant charges for more than 100 restaurants.

"Statements reflect that the American Express credit card charges were paid with public funds," documents said.

Attorneys for the couple filed a motion Friday to dismiss 14 of the 38 charges, including all American Express and tax-related charges.

Ivy Academia operates four campuses, in Woodland Hills, Winnetka, West Hills and Chatsworth, that serve 1,100 students from kindergarten to 12th grade.

Allegations of misuse and co-mingling of public funds first arose against Selivanov and Berkovich in an LAUSD Inspector General audit in 2007. Even after that, however, LAUSD officials gave Ivy a five-year renewal in June 2008.

Los Angeles Unified officials recently called for the couple to step down from managing day-to-day operations at Ivy Academia and abandon their positions on the school's board of directors to avoid being shut down for as long as they are being investigated for the criminal charges.

Parker Hudnut, LAUSD's executive director of innovation and charter schools, said Berkovich and Selivanov have stepped down from Ivy Academia's board of directors and have hired an interim executive director.

"Unless sufficient safeguards are in place to protect public funds... LAUSD retains its right to proceed to revocation," Superintendent Ramon Cortines said in a written statement.

"I am insisting that we keep an even closer eye on Ivy Academia — if it continues to operate."

Hudnut sought to reassure parents of the school.

"We don't want parents scared that we are going to arbitrarily shut down their school," Hudnut said.

"As long as Ivy cooperates with our demands and the ongoing work, the school will remain open."

____________________


► BELL MUST GIVE UP $2.9 MILLION IN ILLEGAL PROPERTY TAXES: BY LAW, THE MONEY MUST GO TO SCHOOLS IN THE CITY.

State Controller John Chiang orders officials to roll back the tax rate, but homeowners won't get a refund. By law, the money must go to schools.

By Kim Christensen, Ruben Vives and Evan Halper, Los Angeles Times

August 14, 2010 - The city of Bell illegally raised its property taxes in 2007 and must immediately give up $2.9 million it has collected since then, state Controller John Chiang said Friday.

Chiang ordered Bell to immediately reduce the "retirement tax" rate, which its City Council increased in 2007 to cover rising pension costs for its employees. The reductions will apply to the next round of property taxes due in November, said Jacob Roper, a spokesman for Chiang.

"Taxpayers should not have had to pay that money," Roper said.

The controller's finding appears to confirm longstanding complaints from Bell property owners that they were being overtaxed. The Times reported last month that Bell officials collected huge paychecks, that the city had cut police and other services and that its property owners were paying higher tax rates than all but one city in Los Angeles County.

The owner of a home in Bell with an assessed value of $400,000 will save about $360 a year because of the cut, an official with the Los Angeles County auditor-controller's office said Friday.

But Bell residents won't be getting a tax refund. According to state law, the nearly $3-million overpayment cannot be refunded to taxpayers and must instead go to schools in the city, Roper said.

smf chimes in: (sorry) The City Of Bell has become a laughingstock in recent weeks. It is important that this money be allocated and legally well spent. The $2.9 million should not go to LAUSD’s general fund. It should not go to the local district or become part of the school board member’s discretionary fund. It should not go to the Southeast Cities Schools Coalition – a leftover from Mayor Tony’s ‘Council of Mayors’ ….some of those folks are some of the same wonderful folks who created the whole Bell Fiasco. It should be spent by the schools in Bell on what the schools in Bell want and need with the input of the community. And every single cent should be accounted for to the unfortunately generous taxpayers of Bell with the thanks of the schoolchildren.

Chiang's order marked the latest twist in a scandal that broke last month when The Times reported that the working-class city of about 39,000 was paying its administrators and police chief the largest municipal salaries in the state, if not the country, with City Manager Robert Rizzo making nearly $800,000 a year.

On Friday, some Bell residents said they were angry about being overtaxed but that they found the controller's findings vindicating.

"As a resident and property owner I am very outraged," said Ali Saleh, co-founder of the Bell Assn. to Stop the Abuse. "This proves all the complaining we have done about the high taxes is true."

Bell resident Huitzil Arenas, 43, agreed, adding: "I'm very angry.... They stole money from the people."

Bell's interim city manager, Pedro Carrillo, said Friday that auditors from the state controller's office discovered the overcharge Thursday night. The City Council is expected to vote on a resolution Monday that will lower the tax rate, he said, and Bell will repay the $2.9 million from a $5-million reserve fund.

"We haven't determined what the fiscal impact of this is yet," he said.

The focus of Chiang's action Friday is a so-called retirement tax, which was approved by local voters in 1944 and made property owners responsible for some of the cost of municipal employees' pensions.

For at least 20 years prior to 2007, the retirement tax had stayed at the same rate of 0.187%.

In 2007, the City Council passed a resolution calling for a series of increases over the next three years. The current rate is 0.277%, or roughly 50% higher than it was three years ago.

On Friday, Chiang ordered the rate rolled back to 0.187%.

Roper, the controller's spokesman, said the amount of property tax that residents can be assessed for pension costs are capped by the tax code to the rate Bell applied in 1984. Increases the City Council set in motion starting in 2007 are illegal, he said.

Roper said the controller's office is unaware whether the property tax increase was implemented concurrently with increased pension benefits for local officials, or if it was intended to be used to cover existing contracts.

The former officials' salaries and Bell's hefty property taxes contrast sharply with city residents' financial standing. Median household income in Bell, just southeast of Los Angeles, is $40,556 —- well below the countywide average of $57,152.

The district attorney and state attorney general have launched investigations into the high pay, as well as allegations of voter fraud and improper property transactions.

Carrillo and interim City Atty. Jamie Casso said they are intent on getting to the bottom of the property tax issue and other alleged improprieties.

"This is why we've been working with the state controller and our city attorney," Carrillo said. "And that is to fix whatever is broken — and it seems we are finding a lot of that."

He also said the city is exploring options for making rebates to residents for their retirement tax overpayment.

All county property owners pay a 1% general property tax, along with special or direct assessments levied by their municipalities. The countywide average of all tax rates is 1.16%, or $11.60 for every $1,000 of assessed value.

Bell's total property tax rate is 1.55%.

That means the owner of a home in Bell with an assessed value of $400,000 pays about $6,200 in annual property taxes. The owner of the same house in Malibu, whose rate is 1.10%, would pay just $4,400.

Bell's high tax rate is due to several factors, records show, including bond debt for municipal improvements such as a sports complex now under construction. Since 2006, county records show, Bell's local taxes have doubled, as have direct assessments for trash collection, sewer maintenance and other services.

Even with the retirement tax cut, Bell's overall rates will remain higher than many cities in the county, in part because of a 0.09% assessment that kicked in this year to cover the bond debt, which was approved by voters.

Revenue from the tax increases went to designated funds or services and did not directly pay for administrators' salaries. But by freeing money from the city's general fund, the higher taxes appear to have made the outsized salaries more feasible for the small city.

Miguel Sanchez, 33, said he paid $5,403 in property taxes in 2009, up from $4,866 the year before.

"It was hitting us hard," Sanchez said. "We knew our property taxes in Bell were high. But I'm very upset about this. Enraged really."


HIGHLIGHTS, LOWLIGHTS & THE NEWS THAT DOESN'T FIT: The Rest of the Stories from Other Sources
UCLA STUDY: “…CHARTERS WERE ACTING AS HAVENS FOR WHITE STUDENTS” - The reality is that charter schools have become... http://bit.ly/cqAOXH a

POLITICAL DETERMINATION SALVAGES FUNDS TO KEEP TEACHERS TEACHING: Themes in the News for the week of Aug. 9-13, 20... http://bit.ly/c9Vydw

GRADING THE TEACHERS: WHO’S TEACHING L.A.’S KIDS?: A Times analysis, using data largely ignored by LAUSD, looks at... http://bit.ly/9rE3xm

VIRTUAL HIGH SCHOOL OPENING THIS FALL IN LOS ANGELES: By Connie Llanos, Staff Writer | LA Daily News History te... http://bit.ly/c73xQz

BELL MUST GIVE UP $2.9 MILLION IN ILLEGAL PROPERTY TAXES: By law, the money must go to schools in the city.: State... http://bit.ly/bdRYvA

Learning Curve: STUCK IN THE MIDDLE: By Maureen Downey | Get Schooled Blog/Opinion in the Atlanta Journal Con... http://bit.ly/dpx5ix

School Reform in Chicago: HALF OF CHICAGO CHARTER SCHOOLS RUN DEFICITS + LITTLE EQUITY, MANY BUDGET LANDMINES IN C... http://bit.ly/dps7kK

SUMMER SCIENCE CAMP GIVES HOMELESS CHILDREN A CHANCE TO EXPLORE: The program, organized by Cal State Long Beach, p... http://bit.ly/cgRUDD

Court Documents: IVY ACADEMIA CHARTER SCHOOL OFFICIAL MISUSED $200,000 IN PUBLIC FUNDS: By Connie Llanos, Staff Wr... http://bit.ly/ccRwd8

U.S. to States: COME GET YOUR EDUCATION JOBS FUND MONEY: By Alyson Klein | Education Week August 13, 2010 2:35 ... http://bit.ly/crPdkv Friday, August 13, 2010 5:35:11 PM via twitterfeed

LINCOLN HIGH, SAN FERNANDO MS PILOT SCHOOLS TO OPEN ON TIME: By Gloria Angelina Castillo, EGP Staff Reporter | Eas... http://bit.ly/9nTA0x

SCHOOLS PACK IN MORE KIDS TO COPE WITH CUTS: By Diana Lambert | Sacramento Bee Friday, Aug. 13, 2010 | Californ... http://bit.ly/c5Hmvy

Showtime: CALIFORNIA SCHOOL CHIEFS COMPETE FOR RACE TO THE TOP DOLLARS: Kitty Felde | KPCC Aug. 11, 2010 | It was... http://bit.ly/c6gxLa

FIFTY WORDS @ FIFTY: We really like Green Eggs and Ham, we really like them Sam I Am.: by smf for LAKidsNews Aug... http://bit.ly/by7Uwb

$26 BILLION TO SCHOOLS, MEDICS - HOUSE: Emergency House session aids health services, saves jobs of laid-off teach... http://bit.ly/bjZAvh

MANY SCHOOLS ON CONTROVERSIAL REFORM LIST MAY NOT GET A DIME OF $416 MILLION: “LA … didn't include enough struggli... http://bit.ly/bOtUpb

LEGISLATURE ADOPTS DEMOCRATIC BUDGET PLAN: With the caveat - Caution: This is a preliminary analysis of the budget... http://bit.ly/dvA4Pj

LOS DESAPARECIDOS: Reality of An LA Urban School: News Feature by Yolanda Arenales | La Opinión/New Amer... http://bit.ly/cITFFG

NEW SCHEDULE BEGINS FOR SOME LAUSD CAMPUSES: Officials say 'balanced traditional' calendar will help students lear... http://bit.ly/bSVFN7

California Alliance for Arts Education: OPPOSE AB 2449 & AB 35: California Alliance for Arts Education E-mail blas... http://bit.ly/bFqq4J

EDUCATION SECRETARY DUNCAN ANNOUNCES $115.2 MILLION FOR 124 GRANTS TO IMPROVE TEACHING OF AMERICAN HISTORY: from T... http://bit.ly/cRiXAL

Birmingham Charter HS & Daniel Pearl Magnet HS: TENSIONS AFTER CHARTER CONVERSION RESULT IN LAWSUIT: By Aleksandr ... http://bit.ly/cy346v


EVENTS - Coming up next week: TALES OF TWO SCHOOL DISTRICTS: LAUSD’s HUGE DISPARITIES & HOW TO FIX THEM
Upcoming Town Hall - from 89.3 KPCC/Southern California Public Radio

* Student A attends El Camino Real High School in Woodland Hills, one of the top-achieving public schools in the state, a school that is a regular finalist in national Academic Decathlon competitions with plenty of advanced placement classes available, located in a bucolic upper-middle class neighborhood.

* Student B attends Belmont Senior High School in Westlake, a struggling school with an unbelievable 60% drop out rate where 80% of its students qualify for federal free or reduced lunches and students’ proficiency rates in both math and reading hover around 50%.

How can two schools in the same district produce such wildly different results? This is the tale of the Los Angeles Unified School District, which with 617,000 students is one of the nation’s largest and most unwieldy, with huge disparities in access to good classrooms, teachers and coursework.

Join Patt Morrison and guests on Thursday, August 19th at KPCC's Crawford Family Forum as we hear stories from students themselves about the differing experiences of going to school in the LAUSD and what can be done to bridge the educational gap.

Thursday, August 19, 2010
7:30 p.m. - 9 p.m.

The Crawford Family Forum
474 S Raymond Ave.
Pasadena, CA 91105
Get directions

RSVP for this event | http://bit.ly/b3VCOK

7:00p.m.--Doors Open
7:30p.m.--Program

ADMISSION is FREE but please RSVP

Sponsor: 89.3 KPCC/Patt Morrison

*Dates and times subject to change. ________________________________________
• SCHOOL CONSTRUCTION BOND OVERSIGHT COMMITTEE:
http://www.laschools.org/bond/
Phone: 213-241-5183
____________________________________________________
• LAUSD FACILITIES COMMUNITY OUTREACH CALENDAR:
http://www.laschools.org/happenings/
Phone: 213-241.8700


• LAUSD BOARD OF EDUCATION & COMMITTEES MEETING CALENDAR



What can YOU do?
• E-mail, call or write your school board member:
Yolie.Flores.Aguilar@lausd.net • 213-241-6383
Tamar.Galatzan@lausd.net • 213-241-6386
Monica.Garcia@lausd.net • 213-241-6180
Marguerite.LaMotte@lausd.net • 213-241-6382
Nury.Martinez@lausd.net • 213-241-6388
Richard.Vladovic@lausd.net • 213-241-6385
Steve.Zimmer@lausd.net • 213-241-6387
...or your city councilperson, mayor, the governor, member of congress, senator - or the president. Tell them what you really think! • Find your state legislator based on your home address. Just go to: http://bit.ly/dqFdq2 • There are 26 mayors and five county supervisors representing jurisdictions within LAUSD, the mayor of LA can be reached at mayor@lacity.org • 213.978.0600
• Call or e-mail Governor Schwarzenegger: 213-897-0322 e-mail: http://www.govmail.ca.gov/
• Open the dialogue. Write a letter to the editor. Circulate these thoughts. Talk to the principal and teachers at your local school.
• Speak with your friends, neighbors and coworkers. Stay on top of education issues. Don't take my word for it!
• Get involved at your neighborhood school. Join your PTA. Serve on a School Site Council. Be there for a child.
• If you are eligible to become a citizen, BECOME ONE.
• If you a a citizen, REGISTER TO VOTE.
• If you are registered, VOTE LIKE THE FUTURE DEPENDS ON IT.


Who are your elected federal & state representatives? How do you contact them?




Scott Folsom is a parent leader in LAUSD. He is Past President of Los Angeles Tenth District PTSA and represents PTA on the LAUSD Construction Bond Citizen's Oversight Committee. He is an elected Representative on his neighborhood council. He is a Health Commissioner, Legislation Team member and a member of the Board of Managers of the California State PTA. He serves on numerous school district advisory and policy committees and has served as a PTA officer and governance council member at three LAUSD schools. He is the recipient of the UTLA/AFT 2009 "WHO" Gold Award for his support of education and public schools - an honor he hopes to someday deserve. • In this forum his opinions are his own and your opinions and feedback are invited. Quoted and/or cited content copyright © the original author and/or publisher. All other material copyright © 4LAKids.
• FAIR USE NOTICE: This site contains copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. 4LAKids makes such material available in an effort to advance understanding of education issues vital to parents, teachers, students and community members in a democracy. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes.
• To SUBSCRIBE e-mail: 4LAKids-subscribe@topica.email-publisher.com - or -TO ADD YOUR OR ANOTHER'S NAME TO THE 4LAKids SUBSCRIPTION LIST E-MAIL smfolsom@aol.com with "SUBSCRIBE" AS THE SUBJECT. Thank you.