Sunday, September 05, 2010

Teaching to the next test


4LAKids: Sunday 5•Sept•2010 LABOR DAY WEEKEND
In This Issue:
• Testing to the Top: NEW COMMON CORE TESTS TO SHELVE “MODIFIED ACHIEVEMENT STANDARDS” FOR SPECIAL ED, OPENS TESTING TO K AND 1st GRADE
• A MATTER OF TIME BEFORE EXIT EXAM’S EXIT
• CHARTER SCHOOLS MUST NOW COMPLY: Principal confesses fraud to board member + CHARTER SCHOOL SCANDAL COULD BOLSTER TRANSPARENCY BILL
• BACK-TO-SCHOOL BLUES (and some reasons for hope)
• HIGHLIGHTS, LOWLIGHTS & THE NEWS THAT DOESN'T FIT: The Rest of the Stories from Other Sources
• EVENTS: Coming up next week...
• What can YOU do?


Featured Links:
• 4 LAKids on Twitter
• PUBLIC SCHOOLS: an investment we can't afford to cut! - The Education Coalition Website
• 4LAKids Anthology: All the Past Issues, solved, resolved and unsolved!
• 4LAKidsNews: a compendium of recent items of interest - news stories, scurrilous rumors, links, academic papers, rants and amusing anecdotes, etc.
WE - whoever "we" are - have just invested a whole lot a angst, sturm und drang - not to mention column-inches, media-minutes and bandwidth - in whether test scores from the California Standards Test (CST or STAR) - tests taken by students that don't effect their grades-or-futures - should be used in some way to evaluate teacher effectiveness. And job-worthiness. Not ability really ...but what my friend and former writing partner correctly calls 'capability'.

The unresolved question/point of contention, is whether standardized tests taken by students are a way to evaluate teacher performance - whether as a snapshot-in-time ...or assessed over time.

ON THURSDAY THE WHOLE WRETCHED MESS WAS MADE MOOT, even as the LAUSD Board of Ed committed itself, the District, 45,000 teachers and 680,000 kids to CST Test Data Driven Reform. The CST/STAR test will be no more, replaced by a new national test. LAUSD will be data-driven by an Edsel, an Oldsmobile, a Pontiac. As it was written so it shall be done!

The Dept of Ed - Arne's Army of Reformers and Reconstitutors - has held yet another heat of Race to the Top, another competition for the dwindling federal largess: WHO CAN COME UP WITH THE MOST BEST-EST TEST EVER?

And the winner is......?
Well, it certainly isn't kids or teachers.

"TEST BABY TEST!"

A fundamentally new test - which still only measures Mathematics and English Language Arts -
waives most exemptions for Special Ed and opens standardized testing to Kindergarten and First Grade - means that all the results and data accumulated so far are meaningless. What was before was Apples; we are in the age of Oranges now! Reboot/Reset/Retest.. You teachers - named+blamed+shamed last Sunday for seven years of past results? Never mind!

We are agreed that we want to measure something - but the feds have thrown away the measuring stick. We are back at Square One, both feet firmly planted in Year Zero. And holding..

The CST is dead, long live the new test. The only constant in life is change and few - certainly not 4LAKids - will be sad to see the CST relegated to history's dustbin - along with Iowa Test of Basic Skills, old spirit-duplicator exams with their purple ink and intoxicating alcohol smell, Dick & Jane; and Mr. McGuffey’s Reader. (The word 'dustbin' itself is sadly a dustbin word.)

When you read the stories about the Brave New Test below [LINKS labeled "Testing to the Top" follow] - the fawning self-congratulation of the DoE press release, the Achieve explainer, the LA Times story that misses the point because this time the testing story isn't about The Times. And pay particular attention to the Man Behind the Curtain: “'This is going to change the way children are taught,' U.S. Secretary of Education Arne Duncan said about the new nationwide tests."

¿If Arne isn't saying that children will be taught to this new test ...what IS he saying?

Maybe the good news is that it appears that the giant test publishers cartel - those wonderful folks who brought us the CST and the Texas Assessment of Knowledge and Skills (TAKS), and the FCAT: the Florida Comprehensive Assessment Test® will be out of the loop this time. Don't bet on it; the money isn't in publishing - it's in consulting. Big money always follows more money. This piece of language: "The (Proposal Design T)eam will work with an advisory group of national and international experts to create the assessment system design during the proposal development phase" leaves the door open for the test companies and the Billionaire Boys Club Foundation Network.

RACE TO THE TROUGH v.2.1

The New National test will be written by a 'committee of 28 states' - of which California is the most populous, with the most schools and students -- and the most at stake. But California is not a lead "governing" member; CA is among second-tier partnership states that are "unable to provide staff time to the design team but will provide rapid feedback on drafts of the proposal through the development phase".

We are passengers on the Bus of Ed Reform. The Governing States/Drivers of The Bus are Florida, Indiana, Louisiana, Massachusetts, New York, Rhode Island, Tennessee, and the District of Columbia - states fully invested in No Child Left Behind and Race to the Top, with mayoral control, pro-charter - and - in varying degrees - anti teacher's union agendas.

The Brave New Test Design Team is consortium – the Partnership for Assessment of Readiness for College and Careers, facilitated by ACHIEVE - a think-tank school-reform advocacy group in turn sponsored by the Gates Foundation among others. Not a lot of dots to connect.

[This footnote is oft repeated in these pages: See "The Billionaire Boys Club" (Chapter 10) in Diane Ravitch's The Death and Life of the Great American School System: How Testing and Choice Are Undermining Education - for the sordid details.]

RACE TO THE TROUGH MEETS CATCH 22

Is it just me - or are we developing the test before we develop and agree on national standards? Will we develop standards to the test? Curriculum to the test? Will textbook authors write to the test? Will teachers be hired, evaluated and laid-off-and-rehired to the test? That really WILL change how students are taught!

HIGH STAKES TESTING

The myth of high stakes testing being high-stakes for the students who take the test is just that. For all of our adult focus and drama about tests and testing, the stakes are low for the kids and they know it.

The question is asked: "Does this test count towards my grade?"
"Will admissions officers look at my CST scores?"
And the answers are: "No."

(Read Fensterwald's "Educated Guess" below - The CAHSEE/High School Exit Exam - the only high stakes test that kids take that does matter to them is apparently on the cutting room floor.)

A HIGH SCHOOL TEACHER WRITES 4LAKids: "Having been in the “Edumacation” business for the past 21 years, (OMG - NOT THAT LONG!), I have administered 21 years worth of those systematized tests and for the most part found them to be useless. The students, once they realize this test is meaningless, (for it is never used except by individual schools to “gauge” improvement – it doesn’t have any bearing on college entrance), virtually ignore the test. Some take it seriously, however, many just mark “C” in each column, then sleep. To gauge a teacher’s capability on those scores is ridiculous."

[*OK - Full Disclosure: This particular teacher was my writing partner when we were in the show biz. Professionally we finished each others sentences. So shoot me!]

The stakes are only high for statisticians, education theorists, beancounters, academe, the LA Times, and the Testing+Textbook Companies - and potentially for those teachers whose students have figured out that the tests don't matter.

THAT SAID, THIS PRESENTS AN OPPORTUNITY.

We - and we all know who "we" are - can create a test and methodology that measures real progress, real ability, real potential, real capability - real outcomes for real kids - beyond mathematics and English language arts Not Achievement - which is driven by scores; but Attainment: measured by Goals. Not with Adequacy or Proficiency or 'Every-child-above-average' as the goal - but Excellence. We won't do it if we are 'unable to provide staff time to the design team or by providing rapid feedback on drafts of the proposal through the development phase'. We must be the change.

Either that or we let politicians, billionaires, special interests and the especially interested come up with a shiny NEW+IMPROVED (the two most dangerous words in marketing) TEST - and then we can teach to that puppy while compiling data to inform instruction. Whatever "they" want that to mean.

¡Onward/Adelante! -smf

________________

BUT WAIT ...THERE'S MORE: I don't normally open e-mails with "No Subject" as the subject - I figure if the writer doesn't know what its about I don't need to know either. Last week I got a threatening "No Subject" missive from the LA Times - taking 4LAKids to task for redistributing Times articles in their entirely and/or not putting in links back to the original source material. ¶ 4LAKids does its best to cite sources and writers - but is loathe to edit material. (I'm a writer ...every word is a favorite child!) I attempted for a short while to truncate material and link to the full article - and caught a lot of negative feedback from readers on that. As your blogger I follow the links - perhaps so you don't have to. I don't spoon feed readers the news ...but I serve it up on the plate! ¶ I understand The Times complaint - advertisers support newspapers' online and print content - and 4LAKids doesn't forward the ads. (The LA Times always has click-thru ads for charter schools in their online education stories - there is value in you knowing who pays for some of this stuff.- but for 4LAKids to run ads for charter schools would cross the line from irony to farce.) ¶ So - gentle readers and Mr. XXXX from the Times - 4LAKids will attempt (no promises made) to place bit.ly links back to the original article in the byline - and suggests to the readership that they support the advertisers that sponsor the content they like and vice-versa. ¶ Incidentally - 4LAKids believes that it's redistribution of news content is ethical and legal under the Fair Use Doctrine. [sections 107 through 118 of the copyright law (title 17, U. S. Code)]

__________________________________________

Testing to the Top: OVERVIEW OF THE PARTNERSHIP FOR ASSESSMENT OF READINESS FOR COLLEGE AND CAREER: NOTE by smf fo... http://bit.ly/bROSD5

Testing to the Top: CALIFORNIA TO USE NEW TYPE OF NATIONWIDE SCHOOL TESTS - Through a federal grant, California wi... http://bit.ly/a2pNnl

Testing to the Top: TWO STATE GROUPS WIN FEDERAL GRANTS FOR COMMON TESTS: By Erik W. Robelen | EdWeek - Vol. 30, I... http://bit.ly/dD31Mw

Testing to the Top: SECRETARY OF ED DUNCAN ANNOUNCES WINNERS OF COMPETITION TO IMPROVE STUDENT ASSESSMENTS - Two w... http://bit.ly/92tRWG


Testing to the Top: NEW COMMON CORE TESTS TO SHELVE “MODIFIED ACHIEVEMENT STANDARDS” FOR SPECIAL ED, OPENS TESTING TO K AND 1st GRADE
By Christina Samuels in EdWeek | http://bit.ly/dCyT0P

September 2, 2010 3:45 PM | I've been pecking away at an article about the push toward common academic standards and students with disabilities for a little while now, but this tidbit is too interesting to hold on to: Today, Education Secretary Arne Duncan announced the winners of a competition to design tests that will accompany these state standards. In his remarks, he made several direct references to what these new tests may mean for students with learning differences:

This new generation of mathematics and English language arts assessments will cover all students in grades 3 through 8 and be used at least once in high school in every state that chooses to use them. In addition, the [Partnership for Assessment of Readiness for College and Careers] consortium will develop optional performance tasks to assess literacy and mathematics knowledge and skills in kindergarten through 2nd grade.

All English language learners and students with disabilities will take the new assessments, with the exception of the 1 percent of students with the most significant cognitive disabilities. Unlike existing assessments, which often retrofit mediocre accommodations into tests, the new assessment systems will be designed, from the start, to accurately assess both English learners and students with disabilities and provide appropriate accommodations. And for the 1 percent of students with the most significant disabilities, states will have funds to develop an alternate assessment as a result of a soon-to-be completed competition.

Notably missing from that statement is any reference to alternate assessments based on modified achievement standards, known as "2 percent tests." That's because the 2 percent tests shouldn't be needed any more among the states that choose to shift to the new assessments, the Education department confirmed to me in an interview.

In 2005, then-Education Secretary Margaret Spellings announced a plan to let states create tests for students who don't have severe cognitive disabilities, but are unable to demonstrate their knowledge on the regular tests.There's no limit to the number of students who can take such tests, but the hypothesis is that only about 2 percent of all students—about 20 percent of students with disabilities—would need them. Therefore, the department only allows proficient scores from 2 percent of the students taking the modified achievement test to be used for calculating adequate yearly progress.

(As Duncan noted, states are also allowed to use a so-called 1 percent assessment, intended for 1 percent of students with the most severe cognitive disabilities. A separate development competition will be held for that test so that it can be aligned to common academic standards.)

The old tests are expected to remain in place until the new assessments are ready to go. Right now, the plan is to field-test new assessments in 2013-14, and have them ready for the classroom in 2014-15. The federal government is not requiring any state to change to the new tests, but many are expected to make the shift.

There's no question that one of the most vexing issues in special education is developing tests for students with learning differences. What accommodations can students use? How do you modify test language without changing what the assessment is meant to measure? How can students reading on a 3rd grade level be tested on standards for 6th graders?

The difficulty is illustrated by the fact that only one state thus far, Texas, has been able to create an alternate achievement assessment that meets Education Department muster.

But Duncan, in his speech, indicates he has pretty high hopes:

For the first time, state assessments will make widespread use of smart technology. They will provide students with realistic, complex performance tasks, immediate feedback, computer adaptive testing, and incorporate accommodations for a range of students....

And last but not least, for the first time, the new assessments will better measure the higher-order thinking skills so vital to success in the global economy of the 21st century and the future of American prosperity. To be on track today for college and careers, students need to show that they can analyze and solve complex problems, communicate clearly, synthesize information, apply knowledge, and generalize learning to other settings.


A MATTER OF TIME BEFORE EXIT EXAM’S EXIT
John Fensterwald - Educated Guess | http://bit.ly/aedrhx

9/02/10 • Nearly 19 out of 20 of seniors in the Class of 2010 who had to take the California High School Exit Exam passed it. That’s great news, in a narrow sense.

But just as record numbers of African-American and Hispanic students are finally passing it, the high school exam itself may be doomed. The awarding on Thursday of $170 million to a consortium of states that includes California to create new national assessments signals its demise. That’s also good news.

California is one of 26 states that are part of Partnership for Assessment of Readiness for College and Careers, one of two groups that the federal government is funding to design standardized tests in line with the common-core standards in math and English that California adopted last month. The focus will now shift to, as PARCC’s name implies, measuring whether students are career and college ready. The state’s exit exam – CAHSEE — has never come close to gauging that.

Notwithstanding the hand-wringing preceding its adoption, attempts to repeal it and the sometimes valiant struggles of students to pass it, CAHSEE is merely a measure of competence with eighth grade math and 10th grade English language arts (with 55 percent of the answers right needed to pass it in math, 60 percent in English). To the extent that students who passed it assumed the exit exam prepared them for challenging work or any sort of post-high school education, the state did them a disservice.

It’s possible that the state will keep CAHSEE; PARCC officials assert their assessments will be compatible with exit exams. But it makes sense that a more sophisticated national test or tests, better aligned to curricula and expectations, will replace it. PARCC, which will be led by the state of Florida and administered by Washington-based Achieve, will have until 2014-15 and gobs of money, to roll out the assessments. The other group of 31 states, led by the state of Washington and San Francisco-based WestEd, will receive $160 million to design its own version. Some states are affiliated with both.

It’s too soon to say what they will look like, but one can imagine a computer-based test along the lines of the California State University’s Early Assessment Program, which most juniors take as a supplement to the 11th grade STAR test, for an indication if they are college-ready. Those who don’t pass it – currently about 80 percent of those who take the English exam and 43 percent of those who take the math portion as juniors – know they have to improve their skills, particularly in expository writing, to avoid remediation as freshmen.

That’s not to say that all students will have to pass an EAP-type test for a high school diploma. There probably would be lower cut scores for a high school diploma and for admission without remediation to a community college and vocational programs. (Some community colleges are now requiring the EAP, too.) The tricky part will be to devise questions testing skills that indicate a readiness for the world of work. The big debates ahead will be what the cut scores should be; each state will have its own ideas.

It would be tragic if the result were more dropouts and a lot fewer high school diplomas. But at the same time, starting as early as eighth grade, students would understand whether they were on track — in course taking and proficiency — for college or meaningful work.

Meanwhile, there was a significant jump this year in CAHSEE completion, with 94.5 percent of the Class of 2010 passing it. This compares with 91.2 percent of the inaugural CAHSEE class to take it, in 2006, and only 90.6 percent last year, although an exemption for special education students was reinstated this year, raising the rate somewhat.

A gap remains between passage rates of whites (98.1 percent this year) and African-Americans (89.7 percent) and Hispanics (91.6 percent), but the passage rate of minorities increased faster: 6 percentage points gain for each group since 2006 (83.7 percent for African-Americans then and 85.5 percent for Hispanics).

It’s better than not that students pass CAHSEE and walk across the stage with a diploma in hand, but many will soon find out that in the outside world, it’s not worth much more than the paper it was printed on.


CHARTER SCHOOLS MUST NOW COMPLY: Principal confesses fraud to board member + CHARTER SCHOOL SCANDAL COULD BOLSTER TRANSPARENCY BILL
• CHARTER SCHOOLS MUST NOW COMPLY: Principal confesses fraud to board member

Written by Andres Chavez, San Fernando Valley Sun Staff Reporter | http://bit.ly/9qOJoL

Thursday, 2 September 2010 -- The Los Angeles Unified school board Tuesday unanimously approved new regulations intended to tighten the district's oversight of charter schools.

The new rules cover the approval and renewal of the independent schools and the procedures for shutting them down if they miss academic benchmarks, engage in fraud, or are fiscally irresponsible.

California law gives charter schools a great deal of autonomy.

But LAUSD Superintendent Ramon Cortines said having clear rules would help effective charters run better and help the district identify problems with less effective schools sooner.

The Board's action was prompted by two sets of allegations of mishandling of funds at San Fernando Valley charter schools. In the first, Ivy Academia, which runs four campuses in the west San Fernando Valley, was charged with 38 counts of fraud and misuse of public funds two months ago.

But what really lit the fire under the Board was the revelation Monday by the LAUSD's Office of Inspector General (OIG) alleging Edward Fiszer, the former principal of NEW Academy Canoga Park, mishandled $2.7 million in public funds, including transferring $1.1 million in school funds into a personal investment account to speculate on the financial market and another million in questionable expenses.

The odd thing about the investigation is that the apparent fiscal misdealing came to light because Fiszer couldn't keep the alleged misdeeds to himself. "It was kind of bizarre.

I asked the OIG office if this was a random audit," said Robert Alaniz, Director of Communications for LAUSD.

"They said 'No, it was brought to our attention by the Board.' Apparently this guy, the former principal, decided he was going to confess to a board member.

Of course, that started the chain (of investigations) rolling." Some of the charges of fraud contained in the OIG report include:

• Withdrawal of funds by NACP's former principal in the form of cashier's checks totaling $1,073,700, which were deposited into the principal's personal investment account.

• Los Angeles County of Education (LACOE) revenue checks totaling $106,351.73 for average daily attendance (ADA) apportionment were untraceable to any of NACP's accounts.

• Use of Professional Services/Consultants for "Related Party Transaction" in the amount of $129,350.

• Use of Professional Services/Consultants without a valid contract in the amount of $400,410.

One of the companies that were supposed to have done school programming didn't exist. There was no phone number or website listed for the company, and the address turned out to be an empty lot.

Superintendent Cortines, in a formal letter dated August 27, 2010, and in compliance with statutory requirements, initiated Charter revocation proceedings against NEW Academy. A public hearing is being scheduled.

Cortines also wants NEW Academy to take the following steps (this is only a partial listing) within the next 45 days:

• Restructure the NACP board of directors, select at least two new financially experienced board members, and train board members in fiduciary responsibility, especially in the oversight of public dollars.

• Implement all of the OIG recommendations within six weeks of the date of this letter.

• Submit the following items for review:

* A framework for proper fiscal oversight of public dollars, including, but not limited to, updated fiscal and accounting policies and controls;
* Evidence of a new back office provider and CPA firm.

Maggie Cervantes, Chairperson for the Board of Directors for New Academy of Canoga Park, responded in a written statement on August 30, 2010:

"The school is taking aggressive and necessary steps to recover its assets and work to successfully resolve this issue.

These steps have included terminating the employment of the former principal of the school. The school also filed criminal charges against the former principal, who is the subject of continued investigation by legal authorities.We will work closely with the LAUSD to implement the recommendations in today's Audit Report, and do not expect any interruption of operations at the school."

According to Alaniz, if the school meets the requirements set out by the district, things should work out. "Our end game is not to shut them down but rather to get them in conformance with business practices that are for the best interest for the kids, the parents and, obviously, the school."

Fiszer seems to have disappeared. One news organization reported that he had left the state.

___________________________________________

• CHARTER SCHOOL SCANDAL COULD BOLSTER TRANSPARENCY BILL
Corey G. Johnson | California Watch Blog | http://bit.ly/aLqkkB

Sept 2 --An audit released this week that accuses a former San Fernando Valley charter school administrator of misusing roughly $2.7 million in taxpayers funds could tip the scales in favor of more transparency and accountability for all charters.

The Los Angeles Times reported that the LA Unified School District's inspector general office found that Edward Fiszer, former principal of NEW Academy Canoga Park, allegedly transferred nearly $1.1 million from the school accounts to his personal Ameritrade account.

Auditors say Fiszer ultimately lost the money speculating on unsuccessful investments in the financial market. The money transfers took place between July 1, 2007 and Sept. 30, 2009, the report stated.

Auditors also contend that Fiszer paid a former teacher $129,450 to be a grant writer, although the school already had a company on contract for grant-writing services. It turns out the former teacher was married to Fiszer, although auditors couldn't pinpoint when.

The audit also questioned $62,247 paid to a company called Burgundy Bunny. Auditors were unable to confirm the business even existed.

The report concluded that the problems were made possible because of a total lack of oversight by the school's board members. Fiszer could not be reached for comment and apparently has left the state, according to the Times.

This latest audit comes weeks after two other San Fernando Valley charter school operators were charged with stealing more than $200,000 in taxpayer funds.

In response to the latest report, LA schools Superintendent Ramon C. Cortines announced he would move to shut down NEW Academy Canoga Park. The school district also moved to change its rules on governing charters.

Vicky Waters, spokeswoman for the California Charter Schools Association, applauded the district's efforts but stressed that all charters shouldn't be tarnished by the actions of a few.

CCSA learned about the report last week. We understand from LAUSD that the report outlines serious issues. We also recognize LAUSD’s appropriate oversight and thoroughness of their investigation. We encourage the school and authorities to take appropriate actions as a result of the report’s findings.

Although we are dismayed at the report's findings, we do not believe that these are indicative of broader issues within the charter movement. We do not want the actions of a few to taint the charter movement, which is comprised of thousands of honest, dedicated and hard-working teachers, parents, leaders, students all working toward better educational opportunities for children.

Currently, charters don't have to comply with laws governing access to records or public meetings. Nor do their boards have to be transparent about spending decisions or what role personal associations play in the awarding of contracts.

For years, advocates have unsuccesfully tried to change that. Stephanie Farland, policy analyst for the California School Boards Association, told California Watch in January that her organization has twice proposed legislation that would make charters abide by the same conflict-of-interest and transparency requirements of other taxpayer-supported schools. Each time, the bills were vetoed by the governor's office – once during the 2003-2004 session and again in the 2007-2008 session.

But neither one of those bills had the force of the Great Recession behind them. And as witnessed in the city of Bell, the public ire has become increasingly less tolerant of public officials using secrecy to abuse public funds.

In comes AB 572, sponsored by Assemblywoman Julia Brownley, D-Santa Monica. The bill would force charter school officials to disclose any conflicts and make their board meetings and minutes open to public scrutiny. The bill's analysis pulls no punches.

Recent news reports of charter school board members engaging in inappropriate financial mismanagement have highlighted the need for charter school conflict of interest laws to be clarified. While charter schools are given more autonomy than public schools, their governing boards have authority over public funds to be used for the educational benefit of their students.

Charter school governing boards should be held to the same standards as school district governing boards.

As of August 26, AB 572 passed both the state Assembly and Senate and is on its way to Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger's desk. Will LA's loss be transparency's gain?
__________________________________


• • smf NOTES: THE CALIFORNIA CHARTER SCHOOLS ASSOCIATION IS OPPOSED TO AB 572 AND ITS CALL FOR TRANSPARENCY IN SPENDING PUBLIC FUNDS –CCSA APPARENTLY SUPPORTS THE STATUS QUO OF CLOSED MEETINGS , FISCAL SHENANIGANS AND ‘THE BROWN ACT BE DAMNED!’.

FROM THE CCSA CAPTOL ALERT (27 Aug):

“This week, AB 572 (Julia Brownley) and AB 2543 (Bonnie Lowenthal) passed the Legislature and were sent to the Governor for his signature or veto. CCSA is opposed to both bills. AB 572 applies draconian conflict of interest policies to charter schools, and AB 2543 applies an unworkable renewal timeline to all charter schools in California.”


BACK-TO-SCHOOL BLUES (and some reasons for hope)
Themes in the News for the week of Aug. 30-Sept. 3, 2010 By UCLA IDEA | http://bit.ly/bTJSD1

09-03-2010 - The beginning of each school year signifies a fresh start—new hopes and resolutions, a new grade level, a new teacher, new supplies and clothes; and yes, learning new stuff: the satisfaction of mathematics, stories from literature and history, wonders of science, and all the rest. Those of us who are years removed from back-to-school moments can still recall both the excitement and apprehension of reentering school halls and classrooms.

Regular readers of these UCLA IDEA Themes might feel more apprehension than most. Much of last year’s education policy news and analysis has been very grim, indeed. What changes can families expect to see at school as a result of a year’s worth of hits to the state’s public education system? And what makes us feel good about California schools?

First, the bad news:

Crowded Classrooms Thousands of layoffs mean teachers will instruct more students. The California Board of Education, which grants requests to increase class sizes in grades with caps to enrollment, gave out 16 exemptions in the past year, but has heard 16 requests last month and expects to hear another 16 this month (Sacramento Bee). Class size increases usually occur in increments of one or two students per year, so the news of an increase doesn’t strike most people as terribly significant—what’s another student or two in a class if it means that a school district can remain solvent? Yet, it doesn’t take many years before California teachers are teaching 44 students in a foreign language class or 39 students in science. A $10 billion federal bill could provide relief, but it’s uncertain how much or when that money will get to schools.

Shorter School Years Some school districts have cut costs with furloughs achieved by eliminating days from the school year. Districts try to restrict furloughs to non-instructional days, but many can’t limit them in that way. Besides, those “non-instruction” days will be sorely missed. These are days that have been used for training, planning, parent conferencing, and other essential activities that schools and teachers will have to pinch from instructional time or drop altogether. California’s calendar has gone down from 180 days to 175 for many students (California Watch, Orange Counter Register).

Bare Bones Classrooms The remaining teachers must make do with less. If they’re not asking students and parents to supply classroom materials or dipping into their own pockets, they’re cutting erasers in half to stretch them out or reaching out to private donors. Schools will continue to see declines in maintenance, technology purchases and repairs, availability of books and paper, and more.

Diminished Programs Summer school continues to be threatened with many programs cuts. Nationwide, programs of all sorts were diminished, including cutting lunches to low-income students. Some programs that provide instruction to juvenile offenders, expelled students, pregnant teens and others who benefit from alternatives to traditional public high schools could be cut or eliminated (Los Angeles Times). As districts cut back on transportation services, families scramble to find reliable and safe ways to get to school. The cuts will be more than just inconvenient. Many students and parents will face added stress, wasted time, and even lost days of work and school.

Lack of School Staff Support Gone are the days of school nurses. Fewer and fewer of them are assigned to one campus anymore. If they have not been laid off, the remaining district nurses are now finding themselves rotating among many different campuses (Sacramento Bee). Guidance counselors, social workers, college and career counselors, and librarians are suffering the same fate.

Uncertainty Schools are realistic, “make-do” institutions. If funding, last-minute program changes, reforms, or teacher hiring (and student assignments and scheduling) are unclear by the first day of school, principals don’t have the luxury of saying they're not ready—that they will push back schools’ first day to November 1. These distracting conditions can turn schools into frantic environments—a condition that wastes time and saps attention to teaching and learning.

So, What’s the Good News?

Teachers and Other School Personnel The vast majority of California teachers are dedicated, caring and skilled. This is easily overlooked in the midst of sensational demands that schools root out teachers who are slackers and incompetents. Most parents say that their own local schools and teachers do a pretty good job (PPIC). Teachers can’t overcome the inadequacies of underfunded and under-resourced schools, but they keep learning alive in classrooms.

Students California students are rich in their diversity and potential. When given appropriate opportunities to learn and the help of caring adults, they work hard and achieve well.

Parents and Communities California has an abundance of neighborhood and community groups that work tirelessly to bring opportunities to students. Some have joined with civil rights organizations, calling on the state to fulfill its constitutional obligations to provide all students a quality education. Others support new programs and schools which are models for what communities want for all of their children. New coalitions of grassroots groups and long-established civic groups are summoning their their values and commitments to public education and their political clout to reestablish education as a top civic priority.


HIGHLIGHTS, LOWLIGHTS & THE NEWS THAT DOESN'T FIT: The Rest of the Stories from Other Sources
PAUL CONRAD 1924-2010: http://bit.ly/8ZSVut

Passion: School Reform | UTLA HEAD A.J. DUFFY FIGHTS TO MAKE UNION PART OF REFORM: By Connie Llanos, Staff Writer ... http://bit.ly/aqMvpZ

L.A. and ARIZONA: WILL DATA CONFLICTS SPUR A CHILL EFFECT?: By Sarah D. Sparks | EdWeek | Vol. 30, Issue 03 | http... http://bit.ly/d5IkoF

DOES TRAINING TEACHERS IN TECHNOLOGY IMPROVE STUDENT ACHIEVEMENT? + TECHNOLOGY HAS CHANGED EDUCATION, BUT IT WON’T... http://bit.ly/drtw0K

Testing to the Top: OVERVIEW OF THE PARTNERSHIP FOR ASSESSMENT OF READINESS FOR COLLEGE AND CAREER: NOTE by smf fo... http://bit.ly/bROSD5

Testing to the Top: CALIFORNIA TO USE NEW TYPE OF NATIONWIDE SCHOOL TESTS - Through a federal grant, California wi... http://bit.ly/a2pNnl

Testing to the Top: TWO STATE GROUPS WIN FEDERAL GRANTS FOR COMMON TESTS: By Erik W. Robelen | EdWeek - Vol. 30, I... http://bit.ly/dD31Mw

Testing to the Top: SECRETARY OF ED DUNCAN ANNOUNCES WINNERS OF COMPETITION TO IMPROVE STUDENT ASSESSMENTS - Two w... http://bit.ly/92tRWG

Controversy? What controversy? - SCHOOL BOARD HOLDS SPECIAL MEETING – AND EITHER REPUDIATES OR EMBRACES OR IGNORE... http://bit.ly/c9tVJ6

LAUSD TO CUT SCHOOL BUS ROUTES, INCREASE WALKING DISTANCE + addl. coverage: Stephane Babcock for School Transporta... http://bit.ly/aIE9Xf

CHARTER SCHOOLS MUST NOW COMPLY: Principal confesses fraud to board member: Written by Andres Chavez, San Fernand... http://bit.ly/c9mXET

CHARTER SCHOOL SCANDAL COULD BOLSTER TRANSPERENCY BILL: Corey G. Johnson | California watch Blog Sept 2 --An audi... http://bit.ly/clmieV

TEACHERS COMMENT ON THEIR VALUE-ADDED EVALUATIONS: Some of the 6,000 L.A. Unified teachers whose rankings were mad... http://bit.ly/d31odg

The Time’s coverage of news of its making continues: LAUSD BOARD MAKES FIRST STATEMENTS ABOUT TEST SCORE ANALYSIS ... http://bit.ly/9MUdOX

State Legislature: SINE DIE*: from the Sacramento Bee Capitol Alert 8PM Aug 31 |In case you missed it: On the l... http://bit.ly/dj8nba

DETAIL OF INSPECTOR GENERAL’S AUDIT OF NOW CHARTER SCHOOL: Sidebar from the Contra Costa Times/LA Daily News Story... http://bit.ly/aP5xGA

UPDATE: Audit finds nearly $3 million fraud at San Fernando Valley charter school: Adolfo Guzman-Lopez | KPCC http://bit.ly/8ZpRYL

$2.7 MILLION IS MISSING AT CHARTER: L.A. Unified moves to close charter school over alleged misuse of funds.: Audi... http://bit.ly/cb1433

UPDATE ON THE STATE BUDGET: Informational Alert August 30, 2010 Update on the State Budget Before ... http://bit.ly/bh1XjR

Podcast Available - “Politics or Pedagogy?: ”WHERE IS THE VALUE IN ‘VALUE-ADDED’? DOES ‘LOS ANGELES ‘ILLUSTRATE TH... http://bit.ly/csdtlI

CALIFORNIA SCHOOLS LOSE RACE FOR THE MONEY: Themes in the News for the week of Aug. 23-27, 2010 By UCLA IDEA staff... http://bit.ly/a8J8Xt

LET’S UNLEASH ALL DATA ON TEACHERS: U.S. SECRETARY OF ED ASKS “WHAT’S THERE TO HIDE?”: BY Arne Duncan | Op-Ed in ... http://bit.ly/a2E7lJ

TEACHERS BLAST L.A. TIMES FOR RELEASING EFFECTIVENESS RANKINGS: The Times made public an analysis of L.AUSD 3rd-5t... http://bit.ly/97sZgR 8:35 AM Aug 30th via twitterfeed


EVENTS: Coming up next week...
*Dates and times subject to change. ________________________________________
• SCHOOL CONSTRUCTION BOND OVERSIGHT COMMITTEE:
http://www.laschools.org/bond/
Phone: 213-241-5183
____________________________________________________
• LAUSD FACILITIES COMMUNITY OUTREACH CALENDAR:
http://www.laschools.org/happenings/
Phone: 213-241.8700


• LAUSD BOARD OF EDUCATION & COMMITTEES MEETING CALENDAR



What can YOU do?
• E-mail, call or write your school board member:
Yolie.Flores.Aguilar@lausd.net • 213-241-6383
Tamar.Galatzan@lausd.net • 213-241-6386
Monica.Garcia@lausd.net • 213-241-6180
Marguerite.LaMotte@lausd.net • 213-241-6382
Nury.Martinez@lausd.net • 213-241-6388
Richard.Vladovic@lausd.net • 213-241-6385
Steve.Zimmer@lausd.net • 213-241-6387
...or your city councilperson, mayor, the governor, member of congress, senator - or the president. Tell them what you really think! • Find your state legislator based on your home address. Just go to: http://bit.ly/dqFdq2 • There are 26 mayors and five county supervisors representing jurisdictions within LAUSD, the mayor of LA can be reached at mayor@lacity.org • 213.978.0600
• Call or e-mail Governor Schwarzenegger: 213-897-0322 e-mail: http://www.govmail.ca.gov/
• Open the dialogue. Write a letter to the editor. Circulate these thoughts. Talk to the principal and teachers at your local school.
• Speak with your friends, neighbors and coworkers. Stay on top of education issues. Don't take my word for it!
• Get involved at your neighborhood school. Join your PTA. Serve on a School Site Council. Be there for a child.
• If you are eligible to become a citizen, BECOME ONE.
• If you a a citizen, REGISTER TO VOTE.
• If you are registered, VOTE LIKE THE FUTURE DEPENDS ON IT.


Who are your elected federal & state representatives? How do you contact them?




Scott Folsom is a parent leader in LAUSD. He is Past President of Los Angeles Tenth District PTSA and represents PTA on the LAUSD Construction Bond Citizen's Oversight Committee. He is an elected Representative on his neighborhood council. He is a Health Commissioner, Legislation Team member and a member of the Board of Managers of the California State PTA. He serves on numerous school district advisory and policy committees and has served as a PTA officer and governance council member at three LAUSD schools. He is the recipient of the UTLA/AFT 2009 "WHO" Gold Award for his support of education and public schools - an honor he hopes to someday deserve. • In this forum his opinions are his own and your opinions and feedback are invited. Quoted and/or cited content copyright © the original author and/or publisher. All other material copyright © 4LAKids.
• FAIR USE NOTICE: This site contains copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. 4LAKids makes such material available in an effort to advance understanding of education issues vital to parents, teachers, students and community members in a democracy. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes.
• To SUBSCRIBE e-mail: 4LAKids-subscribe@topica.email-publisher.com - or -TO ADD YOUR OR ANOTHER'S NAME TO THE 4LAKids SUBSCRIPTION LIST E-MAIL smfolsom@aol.com with "SUBSCRIBE" AS THE SUBJECT. Thank you.



Sunday, August 29, 2010

Seduced+Bedazzled


4LAKids: Sunday 29•Aug•2010 5 Yrs After Katrina
In This Issue:
• NO GOLD STARS FOR SUCCESSFUL L.A. TEACHERS: L.A. Unified has hundreds of excellent instructors. But no one asks them their secrets to success.
• Lopez: HOW TO FIX AN EVALUATION SYSTEM THAT ONE L.A. TEACHER CALLS 'A JOKE'
• VALUE-ADDED IS NO MAGIC: Assessing Teacher Effectiveness
• L.A. SCHOOLS CHIEF VOWS TO USE EVALUATION DATA TO HELP TEACHERS
• HIGHLIGHTS, LOWLIGHTS & THE NEWS THAT DOESN'T FIT: The Rest of the Stories from Other Sources
• EVENTS: Coming up next week...
• What can YOU do?


Featured Links:
• 4 LAKids on Twitter
• PUBLIC SCHOOLS: an investment we can't afford to cut! - The Education Coalition Website
• 4LAKids Anthology: All the Past Issues, solved, resolved and unsolved!
• 4LAKidsNews: a compendium of recent items of interest - news stories, scurrilous rumors, links, academic papers, rants and amusing anecdotes, etc.
The L.A. Times published their database on teacher performance this morning. As we drive our Chevvies to the levee one hopes they hold.


● "As Bad Data Pile up, Options Wane" - 8/27 headline in the LA Times about the economy.

● "We're still so bedazzled by our new gadgets, our new ways of communicating, and certainly they're powerful and very useful. But we're so bedazzled and so seduced by them that we aren't even taking a hard look at the different kinds of thinking that might be lost in this process." -Nicholas Carr on Tavis Smiley 7/6/2010 - Carr's book "Does IT Matter?" began a worldwide debate about the role of computers in business, and his new one, "The Shallows," looks at technology's effect on the mind.

● 4LAKids reminds The Times that while the coder's maxim "GIGO: Garbage In, Garbage Out" is Universal Truth - it is bad interpretation that makes data bad. And, echoing Carr and quoting myself: we are well on the way between being data-driven-to-distraction to being data-driven-to-destruction.. (...or abstraction, dissatisfaction, dissolution - all courtesy of my spell checker.)

As I get older I become fond of repeating myself, and when I tire of that I repeat others. "There are three kids of lies," Disraeli said. "Lies, damned lies and statistics". Another wag said that "under torture, statistics will admit to anything".

In the instance of the LA Times fired Value Added debate - a story more about The Times reporting than it is it is about teachers and education - data and statistics are synonyms - with mistruth not far removed. At best the argument is beset with hollow meaningless disconnected facts illogically proving a false premise.

THE PREMISE: Public Education is a failure,
THE HYPOTHESIS. Failure takes place in the classroom. Teachers are in charge of classroom. Therefore Teachers are to blame.
THE PROOF: 'Value Added' statistical analysis of Standardized Tests identify good and bad teachers.. If we tell parents they will select only good teachers. Let the marketplace decide: Value-Added is IS economic theory.
Case closed.

The Times series is publicly beating up 6000 individual classroom teachers in a reporting style somewhere between Fox News and McCarthy witch hunt - : beating up teachers with the very information The Times claims has been denied to teachers, administrators and parents.
"What don't you know? And when didn't you know it?"

Except, gentle reader, Public Education in middle class communities is not a failure; it really only fails in communities of poverty.

Could poverty be the cause of all this failure?
Could poverty be the reason for the achievement gap?
Do poor children do worse in standardized testing?
"Well..." as the popular vernacular of previous decades had it: "....DUH!"

Or am I a heinous status quo lover misdirecting you from the evil Bad Teacher Menace?

I hope I am not violating the confidence too egregiously, but I was given an important treatise on Value Added last week and asked not to publish it or identify its author. I cannot ion any conscience ignore the truth or the passion.

On this subject the author wrote: "Poverty is an educational issue. Poverty is an educational problem. School, community and family conditions matter. They do not ever, ever determine capacity, potential or ability. Every child can achieve and excel. And our mission towards that excellence guides our every day. But conditions are a factor that affects achievement. It is still the case that (with a few noteworthy exceptions) the map showing concentrations of poverty in Los Angeles and the map showing concentrations of low performing schools are virtually the same map. To ignore this relationship is to abdicate our collective responsibility to eradicate these conditions."

One might claim the recent incremental improvements in test scores results from charter schools or the mayor's partnership or the junk food and soda ban in our schools. Or maybe it's the mantra of "100% Graduation!"- repeated repeatedly without need for amplification that drives us forward.

Or maybe it's the universe of classroom teachers, supported by educators and parents, doing the best they can with what they have in a bad situation unsupported by political will or an adequate budget.

One thing is sure - the recent improvements did not come from investment-in and commitment-to public education by Sacramento or DC; those two are sources of the problem - not the solution, The success of bond measures for local schools proves the community/local voter commitment -- the failure to adequately (let alone equitably) fund school operations in Sacramento and the schizophrenic "Good Cop/Bad Cop" / "Carrot ('Race to the Top') and Stick ('No Child Left Behind')" approach from DC. show a lack of vision, investment and commitment. God Cop/Bad Cop foils petty criminals -- Carrot+Stock is a way to drive a pony cart ...neither are strategies for a cogent state or national education policy.
We need to ratchet up the level of discourse and dialog. We need to a unafraid of identifying and taking on wrong thinking and those who believe that competition and business models and/or privatizing the agenda of public education are magic bullets. Or those who confuse reform with progress. We must educate ourselves.

UTLA and AFT are crying that teacher's unions are being unfairly attacked - but in truth it is Teachers and Educators themselves are being attacked collectively and individually in a disingenuous ploy to "inform parents". LAUSD does not inform parents - but this is not the way to do it! We must rally around them. We must be loud and vocally use our truth


I APOLOGIZE to all six thousand teachers The Times has singled out and named, blamed and shamed today.

Those who are named as The Worst are probably undeserving; those of who get named as The Best may be deserving - but the measuring tool is so suspect they too will to be shamed. Those in the middle can take little glory in that ...and the truly good and the truly bad will skate by unidentified and unrecognized.

Who exactly put newspaper reporters and editorial boards in charge of assessing individual teacher performance anyway? Was it the advertisers or the subscribers? As the Times is bankrupt, maybe it was the creditors.

Listen to the two Jasons and Times reporter Howard Blume talk about+around the internal debate at the Times whether to publish the list here: [http://bit.ly/cHkSz6] They never really name anyone at The Times arguing not to publish. ...and even they seem unconvinced as to the true value of Value Added, They ascribe support to Superintendent Cortines and Arne Duncan and Randi Weingarten and (!)Michelle Rhee. Michelle Rhee has used VA to fire "bad" teachers in DC. - an outcome even the Two Jason argue against!

This debate has brought Public Education Policy front-and-center in L.A. - we are ground zero and the tipping point. in the national debate. We far past the time for summer soldiery and sunshine patriotism - the fight is on and Los Angeles is the battleground.

But if the battle is against teachers rather than poverty and ignorance - if our weapons are amateur data mining and disinvestment - it’s the wrong fight at the wrong time in the wrong venue.

¡Onward/Hasta adelante! - smf


THE DREADED DATABASE - Search by Teacher/Search by School



NO GOLD STARS FOR SUCCESSFUL L.A. TEACHERS: L.A. Unified has hundreds of excellent instructors. But no one asks them their secrets to success.
MOST OF THE TIME NO ONE PRAISES THEM AND OFTEN THEIR PRINCIPALS DON'T EVEN KNOW WHO THEY ARE.

By Jason Felch, Los Angeles Times

August 28, 2010|10:26 p.m. -- It's a Wednesday morning, and Zenaida Tan is warming her students up with a little exercise in "Monster Math."

That's Tan's name for math problems with monstrously big numbers. While most third-graders are learning to multiply two digits by two digits, Tan makes her class practice with 10 digits by two — just to show them it's not so different.

On this spring day, her students pick apart the problem on the board — 7,850,437,826 x 56 — with the enthusiasm of game show contestants, shouting out answers before Tan can ask a question. When she accidentally blocks their view, several stand up with their notebooks and walk across the room to get a better look.

Introducing the LA Times Star Walk app for iPhone. Tour the famous Hollywood Walk of Fame with the Los Angeles Times archives, history and information. Available in the App Store.

The answer comes minutes later in a singsong unison: "Four hundred and thirty-nine billion, six hundred and twenty-four million...."

Congratulations, Tan tells them, for solving it con ganas. That's Spanish for "with gusto," a phrase she picked up from watching "Stand and Deliver," a favorite film of hers about the late Jaime Escalante, the remarkably successful math teacher at Garfield High School in East Los Angeles.

The Los Angeles Unified School District has hundreds of Jaime Escalantes — teachers who preside over remarkable successes, year after year, often against incredible odds, according to a Times analysis. But nobody is making a film about them.

Most are like Zenaida Tan, working in obscurity. No one asks them their secrets. Most of the time, no one even says, "Good job."

Frequently, even their own colleagues and principals don't know who they are.

As part of an effort to shed light on the work of Los Angeles teachers, The Times on Sunday is releasing a database of roughly 6,000 third- through fifth-grade teachers, ranked by their effectiveness in raising students' scores on standardized tests of math and English over a seven-year period.

The findings are based on an approach called value-added analysis, which is designed to allow fair comparisons of teachers whose students have widely varying backgrounds. Although controversial, the method increasingly has been adopted across the nation to measure the progress students make under different instructors.

L.A. Unified has had the underlying data for years but has chosen not to analyze it in this way, partly in anticipation of union opposition. After The Times' initial report this month showed wide disparities among elementary school teachers, even in the same schools, the district moved to use value-added analysis to guide teacher training and began discussions with the teachers union about incorporating data on student progress into teacher evaluations.

The results of The Times' analysis are not a complete measure of a teacher by any means, but offer one way to see whether an instructor is helping — or hindering — children in grasping what the state says they should know.

The Times found that the 100 most effective teachers were scattered across the city, from Pacoima to Gardena, Woodland Hills to Bell. They varied widely in race, age, years of experience and education level. They taught students who were wealthy and poor, gifted and struggling.

In visits to several of their classrooms, reporters found their teaching styles and personalities to differ significantly. They were quiet and animated, smiling and stern. Some stuck to the basics, while others veered far from the district's often-rigid curriculum. Those interviewed said repeatedly that being effective at raising students' performance does not mean simply "teaching to the test," as critics of value-added analysis say they fear.

What's clear from the data is that these teachers have an immediate and profound effect on how much children learn. On average, their students leapt 12 percentile points on tests of English, from the 58th to the 70th. In math, the gains were more stark: a 17 percentile point jump, from 58th to 75th. All in a single year.

The idea of publicly rating teachers by name has generated enormous controversy among educators and experts across the country. The debate has focused on whether the method is sound and the publicity is fair to those with low rankings.

Often lost in that discussion are the benefits of singling out those who consistently succeed.

U.S. Education Secretary Arne Duncan said as much in a speech last week, denouncing a culture in public education that has long been averse to talking about success stories.

"The fact is, rather than shining a light on effective teachers, our education system hides them," he said.

Mystery of good teaching

Experts have long known that highly effective teachers can overcome the challenges students face both inside and outside of school. But why they are so successful — and whether their skills can be passed along to others — remains largely a mystery.

Most of the things districts track about teachers — their age, years of experience, education and credentials — do not appear to matter much, at least when it comes to raising students' performance on tests.

What does matter? Is it chemistry, technique, dedication, rigor? Might it be a thousand smaller, almost invisible things, depending on the subject and type of students?

Hundreds of books purport to answer those questions, but no clear consensus has emerged. And few of the competing theories have been rigorously tested, said Thomas Kane, a leading education researcher at Harvard University.

"It's very difficult for an individual teacher to distinguish between the valuable suggestions and the snake oil," he said.

That's in large part because there is no agreement on how to identify the best teachers. It's something Kane and other education researchers have spent much of the last decade trying to sort out.

In a seminal study in 2008, Kane and a colleague set out to experimentally test the reliability of the value-added approach, which assesses a teacher's effectiveness by measuring the year-to-year gains of each student on standardized tests.

Among other things, some researchers had been concerned about the wide variation in value-added results for individual teachers from year to year, the potential for error in the findings and the possibility that the results would be skewed by how students were assigned to classrooms.

In Kane's experiment, conducted at Los Angeles Unified with administrators' permission, 156 district teachers who volunteered for the project were randomly assigned to classrooms. Kane and his colleague tried to predict, using value-added analysis, how students would do under those teachers. The projections were then compared with the students' actual results.

The conclusion: Value-added analysis was a strong predictor of how much a teacher would help students improve on standardized tests. The approach also controlled well for differences among students, the study found.

With $45 million from the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, Kane and other researchers are now following 3,000 teachers in six school districts to see if other types of evaluation — including sophisticated classroom observations, surveys of teachers and reviews of student work — are also good measures of teacher performance.

In the meantime, Kane said that, although it is not perfect, "there is currently not a better measure of teacher effectiveness than the value-added approach."

Wide-ranging advice

Identifying the most successful teachers is merely a first step. The next is to study them closely and find ways to pass their techniques on to others.

It is no simple undertaking.

Some of the top teachers in The Times' analysis said in interviews that they weren't sure exactly what made them effective, or were skeptical that whatever it was could be distilled and passed on.

Diane Hollenbach, who recently retired from Broadous Elementary School in Pacoima, was the most effective elementary school teacher of the roughly 6,000 analyzed by The Times.

"The ones that love their students and love their job do well," she said. "You can't bottle that, and you can't teach it."

Others had wide-ranging advice for their fellow teachers.

Jilla Sardashti, who taught last year at Parmelee Avenue Elementary School in the Florence-Firestone neighborhood, said she teaches critical thinking skills from the first day of school.

"These kids are as smart as any other kids in the district," said Sardashti, whose students are mostly poor and Latino and often still learning English. "I'm really good at figuring out what they need, and I provide them with experience to know about the world around them."

Hollie Bloch, who retired in July from Balboa Gifted Magnet in Northridge after teaching in the district 39 years, said that challenging students — especially high-achieving ones — was essential.

"I teach Shakespeare to children," she said. "If the teacher's expectations are high, and you have control of the classroom, those kids should do well."

Said Aldo Pinto, a 32-year-old teacher at Gridley Street Elementary School in San Fernando: "The biggest challenge is getting them to buy into the fact that school is important."

He does that by telling students his own story as the son of Mexican immigrants.

Pinto, like most other teachers interviewed, said his good results had not been recognized.

"No one is ever really singled out, neither good nor bad," said Pinto. "The culture of the union is: Everyone is the same. You can't single out anyone for doing badly. So as a result, we don't point out the good either."

"When I worked at a bank, I was employee of the month," he added. "For LAUSD, for some reason, it's not a good thing to do."

Extraordinary achievements

Morningside Elementary in San Fernando is in many ways an average school for the district.

Like students at Parmelee, its pupils are largely poor and still struggling with English. Its test scores are below the state goal but in the middle of the pack for L.A. Unified.

In this very ordinary school, year after year, Tan quietly accomplishes extraordinary things.

In the 2008-09 school year, four of Tan's students started below grade level in math. By the end, they were all advanced. In English, nine of her students started below grade level. All but two ended the year at grade level or higher.

Tan is 62 but looks to be in her 40s. An immigrant like many of her students, she understands what they face. She is still self-conscious about her strong accent from her native Philippines, which she left at 27.

When not teaching, she is a marathon runner, with the wiry frame to show for it. Last spring, she finished Boston's in 4 hours, 20 minutes.

Inside the classroom, she sets a sprinter's pace, at times zipping around her students' desks in an athletic shirt and shorts.

Tan is not reading from a district playbook or drilling her students in how to take tests. She says she has little patience for the district's rigid curriculum and at times ignores it. That gets her into trouble on occasion with district administrators, who urge teachers to stay on the same pace.

Tan brims with innovative ways to reach limited-English students, handle discipline problems and keep the kids engaged. "I do a lot of singing, games," she said. "It doesn't look like a lesson."

But no one asks for her advice. She says her fellow teachers at Morningside consider her strict, even mean. She tends to keep to herself.

"Nobody tells me that I'm a strong teacher," she says.

That's OK by her, she adds. Year after year, she watches her students make enormous progress and feels a quiet sense of satisfaction.

Second-generation success

Tan's students made strong gains in each of the seven years analyzed by The Times. Indeed, she seems to have been pulling students up for a generation.

About twenty years ago, Karina Reyna and her twin sister both had Tan as their first-grade teacher, an experience Reyna still remembers vividly.

The girls had been born in Mexico and entered the U.S. illegally with their parents, neither of whom had graduated from high school. The family lived in a working-class area in San Fernando, where Reyna's father installed carpets.

By first grade, Reyna said, she still didn't speak English. Ms. Tan was determined to change that.

"I really didn't like her," Reyna recalled. "I remember crying every day."

Tan pushed Reyna relentlessly, accepting nothing but her best work. Reyna's English improved, but when she continued to struggle in math, Tan stayed after school to help her catch up.

"Now I recognize it wasn't mean, it was strict," Reyna said. "She was pushing me to do what I was capable of. Maybe she even saw something I didn't see."

Reyna and her sister Daniella stayed in touch with Tan over the years. Tan attended their 15th birthday party and years later Daniella's 2006 graduation from Cal State Northridge, which both sisters attended after becoming U.S. citizens.

"I don't think I'll ever forget her," said Reyna, who works for an insurance company and plans to finish her college degree soon. "Without her, there wouldn't have been somebody saying, 'You have to finish school; you have to go to college.' "

When Reyna learned that her daughter, Jazmin, had been assigned to Tan, she was convinced the girl would thrive.

"I told her, 'She's really strict,' " Reyna recalled. " 'You're going to be pushed, but it's going to be good for you.' "

She was right.

Jazmin entered Tan's class in 2007 above grade level in math. By the end of the school year, she had vaulted 74 points to 600 on the state test — a perfect score.

Having just finished fifth grade, Jazmin was recently accepted into a gifted-magnet middle school. Reyna expects her to graduate from college and go into medicine. She hopes her son, a kindergartener, will also be assigned to Tan.

"She pushes kids to be their best," Reyna said.

Evaluation form limited

Tan measures her success in stories like these.

But by the LAUSD's measure, Tam simply "meets standard performance," as virtually all district teachers do — evaluators' only other option is "below standard performance." On a recent evaluation, her principal, Oliver Ramirez, checked off all the appropriate boxes, Tan said — then noted that she had been late to pick up her students from recess three times.

"I threw it away because I got upset," Tan said. "Why don't you focus on my teaching?! Why don't you focus on where my students are?"

Ramirez said he wants to give more recognition to his excellent teachers, but with no objective measure to rely on, he's concerned about ruffling feathers.

"What about the teachers who feel they should have been recognized?" he said. "There'll be a whole mess. The district knows this would open up a can of worms."

"That's why it doesn't happen."


Times staff writer Doug Smith contributed to this report.


Lopez: HOW TO FIX AN EVALUATION SYSTEM THAT ONE L.A. TEACHER CALLS 'A JOKE'
STEVE FRANKLIN AGREES THAT TEACHERS SHOULD BE JUDGED IN PART ON HOW THEIR STUDENTS DO ON STANDARDIZED TESTS AND IN PART ON PEER REVIEW.

Steve Lopez | LA Times columnist

August 29, 2010 -- Steve Franklin, a middle school teacher in L.A. Unified, had some issues with the Times series on teacher evaluations, so he fired off a letter to the editor. It read, in part:

"When somebody can prove that high test scores produce good citizens, critical thinkers and productive members of society, then and only then can we say the teachers who taught those kids were 'good.' "

Yeah, yeah, yeah, I thought. Test scores aren't always the best measure of students or teachers, but without them, how do we judge the performance of either?

Under Franklin's letter, he was identified as a teacher at Sun Valley Middle School and as an LAUSD and L.A. County teacher of the year in 2004-05. All right, so he must know a thing or two. I called to see if he'd like to talk about teaching, the Times series and the state of education, and he said sure.

Franklin is 37 and went to Chatsworth High, followed by Cal State Northridge. For graduate school, he went to USC and got a master's in public policy with an education focus, but he almost didn't get in.

Why not?

"I'm not a very good test taker," he said, and he'd scored low on the GRE exam, which was required for admission. But he did well enough on other parts of the application process to make the cut, and of course to go on and become a teacher of the year despite being mediocre at standardized tests.

I could understand: I was a lousy test taker myself.

Franklin said the Times series by Jason Song, Jason Felch and Doug Smith had teachers buzzing. At his school, he said, teachers didn't necessarily disagree with the thrust, but there were hard feelings about individual teachers being singled out by name as being more or less effective based on their students' test scores.

Understandable. But the series has forced a conversation about something I've written about often: We need better ways to evaluate teachers, so we can reward the best ones, help the less effective and dump a corrupting system in which job security and pay are based largely on time served.

The Times dug up data readily available to both the district and the teachers union but not fully analyzed by either. What's the point of paying the cost of standardized tests, and building curriculum around them, if the information isn't put to use in ways that help students learn and make teachers more aware of their own standing among peers?

I was mildly surprised when Franklin said he "absolutely" agreed. He stood by his claim that multiple variables determine how students and teachers perform, and said unmotivated students with disengaged parents bring huge challenges into classrooms. But he called the current system of teacher evaluation "a joke."

A principal or assistant principal will drop in on a classroom at an announced time and date, he said, spend as little as 10 minutes and give the teacher either a "satisfactory" or "unsatisfactory."

Franklin agreed that the "value added" system the Times series focused on — judging teacher proficiency in part by whether students' test scores rise or fall — ought to be one piece of an evaluation. I reminded him that our series had made clear that value-added analysis provided only a piece of the picture. But there is a national trend toward evaluating teachers, in part, by how their students do on standardized tests, and districts that fail to do so — often because of pressure from teachers unions — risk losing federal funds.

I suggested that value-added stats should account for one-third of the evaluation, with a peer-review system counting for the rest of it. Franklin wasn't comfortable choosing percentages but said he thought a peer review team ought to be made up of union reps, fellow teachers, administrators, retired college professors, parents and former students.

"We are public servants," he said, and the task is no menial one. "I think we owe it to the children to try anything that might work. Try it and if it works, implement it. Period."

Because he is a seventh-grade social studies teacher and leadership instructor for all three middle school grades, standardized tests don't apply directly to Franklin, nor do they measure the work of, say, art or P.E. teachers. But he said teachers are aware which instructors seem to have better control of their classes and good instincts for relating to their students, yet little is done by anyone to help the struggling teachers or tap the brains of more effective ones.

And what makes him teacher-of-the-year material?

Some of it is indefinable and perhaps not teachable, said Franklin. But he starts with this principle:

The students don't care how much you know until they know how much you care.

Six times he has taken his leadership students to the White House. Seven times he has taken them to Philadelphia for history lessons. Next year, the plan is for his students to watch fireworks on the Mall in the nation's capital.

Last week, Franklin and most of his Sun Valley colleagues attended a voluntary professional development seminar studying, of all things, ways to put student evaluations to better use in the classroom. There is great talent, he said, among L.A.'s teachers, administrators and union leaders, but they all need to do a better job of working together for the welfare of the students.

I walked away thinking I'd be honored if, one day, my daughter were in Franklin's class.


VALUE-ADDED IS NO MAGIC: Assessing Teacher Effectiveness

by John Rogers, Director, UCLA's Institute for Democracy, Education, and Access In the Huffington Post

August 24, 2010 11:05 AM

That old sorcerer has vanished
And for once has gone away!
Spirits called by him, now banished,
My commands shall soon obey.

In Goethe's classic, the apprentice uses a sorcerer's spell to ease his daily chores. Chanting the master's words, he brings a broomstick to life and tells it to fetch water to clean the workshop. The broomstick obeys, only too well. It races between the well and back until the workshop begins to flood. Although the apprentice had enough knowledge to set magic in motion, he could not think ahead to what he did not know.

I worry about a similar flood of unintended consequences if the Los Angeles Times moves forward with its plans to publish a database that places 6,000 Los Angeles third- to fifth-grade teachers on a spectrum from "least effective" to "most effective." The Times believes that the data will be a powerful tool to force better teaching, but it cannot anticipate all of the consequences. For example, consider that capable prospective teachers might avoid a profession in which they risk public embarrassment based on an undeveloped science. Consider the well-documented estimates that 25% of the value-added assessments are likely to be in error.

Publishing the database might easily undermine parent and teacher morale and make it more difficult for principals to advance school improvement. Being told that their child's teacher is "ineffective," or even marginally less effective than a teacher across the hall, may lead some parents to pressure the principal to place their child with a "high-scoring" teacher. Pitting parents against one another or against their principal is not a recipe for school improvement.

The Times' teacher effectiveness rankings are based on an elaborate statistical model created by Richard Buddin, a senior economist and education researcher at the Rand Corporation. (Significantly, Buddin did not attach teachers' names to his analysis; that was done by the Times.)

Buddin is one of many researchers across the country exploring so-called value-added approaches to assessing teacher quality. The assessments measure gains that students make on standardized tests from one year to the next. For example, researchers compare test scores of fourth graders with their scores as third graders to determine the "value added" by the fourth grade teacher. Proponents believe that the "value added" reliably distinguishes between more and less effective teachers. And they think that school officials would use such comparisons to target support to struggling teachers and motivate them to do better.

Yet value-added analyses focus narrowly on standardized tests, usually in math and English Language Arts. These tests give important information about student learning, but they ignore much learning that matters to students, parents, and teachers. That's why it can be a useful tool, but cannot possibly stand alone as a measure of "effectiveness." The National Academy of Sciences has identified several of the problems posed by value-added methods. These cautions should be taken seriously.

* First, student assignments to schools and classrooms are rarely random. As a consequence it is not possible to definitively determine whether higher or lower students test scores result from teacher effectiveness or are an artifact of how students are distributed.

* Second, it is difficult to compare growth of struggling students with the growth of high performers. In technical terms, standardized tests do not form equal interval scales. Enabling students to move from the 20th percentile to the 30th is not the same as helping students move from the 80th to the 90th percentile. These test score numbers are not like inches along a tape measure that have the same value regardless of where they occur.

* Third, estimates of teacher effectiveness can range widely from year to year. In recent studies, 10-15% of teachers in the lowest category of effectiveness one year moved to the highest category the following year while 10-15% of teachers in the highest category fell to the lowest tier.

The National Academy of Sciences concluded that value-added analysis "should not be used as the sole or primary basis for making operational decisions because the extent to which the measures reflect the contribution of teachers themselves, rather than other factors, is not understood."

And yet, the Los Angeles Times is about to publish a database with the teacher effectiveness rankings of 6,000 elementary school teachers. The Times argues that its role is to provide "parents and the public ... information that would otherwise be withheld" about the "performance of public employees." The Times should not believe in the magic of this data, and should realize that it cannot foresee or control all of the consequences.


L.A. SCHOOLS CHIEF VOWS TO USE EVALUATION DATA TO HELP TEACHERS
by Howard Blume | LA Times

August 25, 2010 | 1:02 pm -- L.A. schools chief Ramon C. Cortines talked about revamping teacher evaluations as a tool for helping teachers improve as part of his final, annual address to administrators Wednesday morning at Hollywood High School.

Overall, the 30-minute speech celebrated progress at various schools, including Hollywood High, and challenged educators to do more.

During his remarks, Cortines emphasized that the nation's second-largest school district plans to develop and adopt a “value-added” measure that uses students test scores to determine individual teachers' and schools' effectiveness. This data should be part of a multifaceted evaluation for teachers, he said.

The value-added method has become a central topic in the Los Angeles Unified School District in the wake of a Times series on the subject. The Times also plans to publish a database later this month containing the value-added rating for about 6,000 third- through fifth-grade teachers. The newspaper found that the school district had the ability to do such an analysis but, like other school systems, never did so.
“It is critical that we look at multiple measures to support our employees,” Cortines said, and “how value added fits into our overall strategy.”

The district plans on publishing such data about schools “once this information has been validated,” he said. Moreover, such efforts should be developed in partnership with employee bargaining units. “Supporting all employees is about creating a culture of collaboration and trust.”

Cortines supported teachers by quoting a Polytechnic High school custodian who talked about how teachers were on campus when he arrived to work and still working when he left for the day.

Cortines -- who plans to retire in 2011 -- lost his composure near the end of his address as he thanked those assembled for the opportunity to work with them. A packed auditorium, that included parents, district officials and community leaders rose for a 45-second ovation as school board president Monica Garcia rushed to the microphone to proclaim Cortines the nation’s best superintendent.

The superintendent also defended the new Robert F. Kennedy complex of six schools built on the site of the Ambassador Hotel at a cost approaching $600 million. He then remarked on his age by noting that he first visited the old hotel when Adlai Stevenson was running for president. His second visit to the hotel, he said, was a youthful streaking episode with some friends. On a second such jaunt, at a different hotel, Cortines said, police collared him and called his father to collect him.

The confession drew extended, warm applause and some uncomfortable chuckles from the largely buttoned-up crowd of more than 1,000.

In a later interview, Cortines talked about California’s unsuccessful bid to win a federal Race to the Top school improvement grant. Cortines had been part of California’s five-member delegation to present the state’s bid. He noted that federal evaluators grilled him on whether his district could obtain union consent for a teacher-evaluation process that includes linking student data to individual teachers. He told federal officials he was confident that the union could be won over to such a plan. He also said the district would take advantage of rules for the next round of funding that would likely allow L.A. Unified to apply directly to the federal government rather than part of a state effort.

Just after his address, the diminutive, 78-year-old superintendent demonstrated that his impending departure is unrelated to physical fitness. He nimbly and swiftly lowered himself off the stage -- a 4 1/2-foot drop -- landing on his feet unharmed among a bank of plants, where well-wishers mobbed him for hugs and photos.

School board member Steve Zimmer called Cortines' expression of emotion “a remarkably pure moment from someone who did not have to take this job except for his lifelong passion for kids and their families. We won’t get another moment like this because there’s not another person like him.”


HIGHLIGHTS, LOWLIGHTS & THE NEWS THAT DOESN'T FIT: The Rest of the Stories from Other Sources
OTHER STUFF IS GOING ON!: RACE TO THE TOP HAS PASSED CALIFORNIA BY AGAIN, ARNE DUNCAN IS TOURING THE SOUTH IN A BIG BLUE BUS SAYING THAT "LOS ANGELES ILLUSTRATES THE PROBLEM", LATER START TIMES IN HIGH SCHOOLS MAY SOLVE (PART OF) THE PROBLEM, VENOR PATTERSON SLIPS FREUDIAN, BACK TO SCHOOL IS UPON US, TEST SCORES ARE UP, ETC. --- Read on!

LA Times publishes ‘Value Added’ database - LOS ANGELES TEACHER RATINGS: MEASURING TEACHER EFFECTIVENESS: from the... http://bit.ly/dx6NZ3

Critique of value-added: ONE NUMBER CAN’T ILLUSTRATE TEACHER EFFECTIVENESS + THE REPORTERS RESPOND: One number can'... http://bit.ly/9lviGM

MEET THE REPORTERS WHO ANGERED THOUSANDS OF TEACHERS: The KPFK interviews of LA Times reporters Jason Felch and Ja... http://bit.ly/cHkSz6

NAMES AND DATA: YES OR NO?: letters to the LA Times | 27 Aug 2010 | more - from other dates - follow Re "L.A.'s ... http://bit.ly/9nIRyv

Headline in today’s LA Times: AS BAD DATA PILE UP, OPTIONS WANE: …unfortunately the story wasn’t about the Times’ ... http://bit.ly/9FEiPd

L.A. SCHOOLS CHIEF VOWS TO USE EVALUATION DATA TO HELP TEACHERS: -- Howard Blume | LA Times August 25, 2010 | 1:... http://bit.ly/9q5rpa

Cortines: LAUSD’s SUCCESS DEPENDS ON CONTINUED EMBRACING OF REFORMS: By Connie Llanos, Staff Writer | LA Daily New... http://bit.ly/cI6VoE

WHERE IS THE VALUE IN ‘VALUE-ADDED’? DOES ‘LOS ANGELES ILLUSTRATE THE PROBLEM’?: john cromshow, host of KPFK’s “P... http://bit.ly/b2GwLG

“Los Angeles illustrates the problem” -- EDUCATION SECRETARY DUNCAN’S SPEECH TO THE CLINTON FOUNDATION IN LITTLE R... http://bit.ly/aWs8QA

“PAGING DR. FREUD, PAGING DR. FREUD – GOVERNOR PATTERSON’S’ SLIP IS SHOWING….”: New York Governor David Patterson ... http://bit.ly/anphfO

Poll: LANGUAGE A BARRIER FOR LATINOS IN SCHOOLS: By HOPE YEN and CHRISTINE ARMARIO, Associated Press Writers AP... http://bit.ly/ahkno2

VALUE-ADDED IS NO MAGIC: Assessing Teacher Effectiveness: John Rogers, Director, UCLA's Institute for Democracy, E... http://bit.ly/aqhcJD

LAUSD SOPHOMORES IMPROVE ON STATE'S HIGH SCHOOL EXIT EXAM + Scores: By Connie Llanos, Staff Writer | Contra Costa ... http://bit.ly/aA3XHV

HEALTHCARE REFORM APPROPRIATIONS UPDATE FROM THE CHILDREN’S ORAL HEALTH PROJECT: CDHP Health Policy Check-Up: The L... http://bit.ly/aPLglS

CALIFORNIA LOSES BID FOR RACE TO THE TOP v. 2.o: Howard Blume – A Times/LA Now blog August 24, 2010 | 8:45 am --... http://bit.ly/9yayoF

DRIVE TO OVERHAUL LOW-PERFORMING SCHOOLS DELAYED: By SAM DILLON | New York Times August 23, 2010 -- SAN BERNARDIN... http://bit.ly/b5JXy6

SHUTTING OUT THE CHARTERS – in which the charter school chief argues that that charter operators can build better ... http://bit.ly/brfOce

Test Score Bomb: DON’T NAME NAMES, FIX THE SYSTEM: The Los Angeles Times teacher rankings bomb has ignited a fires... http://bit.ly/bYTutY

BACK TO SCHOOL TIME IS VACCINATION TIME: Parents should check to make sure students are up to date on required imm... http://bit.ly/cbDyAT

Pro/Con: SHOULD CHOCOLATE MILK BE ALLOWED IN SCHOOLS?: Without it, strategies to replace the nutrients mean more c... http://bit.ly/b0h1Zh

LATER SCHOOL START TIMES: FROM ZZZZ’s TO A’s. A growing body of evidence demonstrates that growing bodies benefit ... http://bit.ly/9lEmnq

CALIFORNIA DELAYS $2.9 BILLION PAYMENT TO COUNTIES, SCHOOLS: from The Huffington Post August 24, 2010 -- SACRAME... http://bit.ly/9WWjW2

DARLINE ROBLES, LA COUNTY SUPERINTENDENT OF SCHOOLS, TO RESIGN: Sent: Friday, August 20, 2010 4:31 PM To: All L... http://bit.ly/avBLlC


EVENTS: Coming up next week...
*Dates and times subject to change. ________________________________________
• SCHOOL CONSTRUCTION BOND OVERSIGHT COMMITTEE:
http://www.laschools.org/bond/
Phone: 213-241-5183
____________________________________________________
• LAUSD FACILITIES COMMUNITY OUTREACH CALENDAR:
http://www.laschools.org/happenings/
Phone: 213-241.8700


• LAUSD BOARD OF EDUCATION & COMMITTEES MEETING CALENDAR



What can YOU do?
• E-mail, call or write your school board member:
Yolie.Flores.Aguilar@lausd.net • 213-241-6383
Tamar.Galatzan@lausd.net • 213-241-6386
Monica.Garcia@lausd.net • 213-241-6180
Marguerite.LaMotte@lausd.net • 213-241-6382
Nury.Martinez@lausd.net • 213-241-6388
Richard.Vladovic@lausd.net • 213-241-6385
Steve.Zimmer@lausd.net • 213-241-6387
...or your city councilperson, mayor, the governor, member of congress, senator - or the president. Tell them what you really think! • Find your state legislator based on your home address. Just go to: http://bit.ly/dqFdq2 • There are 26 mayors and five county supervisors representing jurisdictions within LAUSD, the mayor of LA can be reached at mayor@lacity.org • 213.978.0600
• Call or e-mail Governor Schwarzenegger: 213-897-0322 e-mail: http://www.govmail.ca.gov/
• Open the dialogue. Write a letter to the editor. Circulate these thoughts. Talk to the principal and teachers at your local school.
• Speak with your friends, neighbors and coworkers. Stay on top of education issues. Don't take my word for it!
• Get involved at your neighborhood school. Join your PTA. Serve on a School Site Council. Be there for a child.
• If you are eligible to become a citizen, BECOME ONE.
• If you a a citizen, REGISTER TO VOTE.
• If you are registered, VOTE LIKE THE FUTURE DEPENDS ON IT.


Who are your elected federal & state representatives? How do you contact them?




Scott Folsom is a parent leader in LAUSD. He is Past President of Los Angeles Tenth District PTSA and represents PTA on the LAUSD Construction Bond Citizen's Oversight Committee. He is an elected Representative on his neighborhood council. He is a Health Commissioner, Legislation Team member and a member of the Board of Managers of the California State PTA. He serves on numerous school district advisory and policy committees and has served as a PTA officer and governance council member at three LAUSD schools. He is the recipient of the UTLA/AFT 2009 "WHO" Gold Award for his support of education and public schools - an honor he hopes to someday deserve. • In this forum his opinions are his own and your opinions and feedback are invited. Quoted and/or cited content copyright © the original author and/or publisher. All other material copyright © 4LAKids.
• FAIR USE NOTICE: This site contains copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. 4LAKids makes such material available in an effort to advance understanding of education issues vital to parents, teachers, students and community members in a democracy. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes.
• To SUBSCRIBE e-mail: 4LAKids-subscribe@topica.email-publisher.com - or -TO ADD YOUR OR ANOTHER'S NAME TO THE 4LAKids SUBSCRIPTION LIST E-MAIL smfolsom@aol.com with "SUBSCRIBE" AS THE SUBJECT. Thank you.